Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Properly cross with brother. What to do?

32 replies

DeckSwabber · 20/04/2014 13:44

Context:

One older brother with wife and two young boys. Me single mum with teens. Dad died 30+ years ago. Mum remarried and widowed again 4 years ago.

Mum, 82, now living with her twin 2 hours from where my brother & I live. I've written about this before. It's a delicate situation as Twin is very strong minded and my mum is very wobbly. She is anxious about everything (especially money, although she is fairly well off), has falls, and memory problems. Twin has been horrible to me throughout, eg has prevented me from coming to my mum's hospital or GP appointments (she actually changed an appointment so that I couldn't attend, meaning that my mum had to wait extra time for some test results she was worried about), has told me my mum's health 'is none of my business', and has told me that she has disliked me since I was a little girl. I have POA and look after mum's money, tax etc, but Twin recently swept my mum off to her lawyer and told the family it was because I didn't want to be involved any more (!!!). Luckily I found out and am now in direct contact with the lawyer.

I know my mum feels a bit pushed around by her sister but on the whole she is reasonably happy, is well looked after, and is pleased that I am looking after affairs. I think she has finally realised that her sister has a bit of a 'thing' about me.

So. My brother.

He is a bully. Example - when my mum was 80 I suggested my brother might organise her 80th party (I would have done it if he was too busy but I was not well so it made sense to ask him on this occasion). Previously we had split the cost of her 70th party so I expected to do the same, and we could both afford it. He organised an expensive do. Then he made her pay for every penny of it, even though I was expecting to pay half and my mum was feeling wobbly about money. She often phoned me up in tears about it, saying she had asked him to cancel. He refused to cancel, or to pay, and he refused to let me pay for it 'in case it made him look bad'. It was at a private club where he is a member so not so easy for me to just pay. We had several rows about it but to my eternal shame she paid in the end. The party was for people we all knew so I'm sure they all thought he was a top bloke for organising. She was badly shaken by being forced.

I took that as a warning about what he is like, and since then I have been very guarded around him.

Then we had to work together to sell her house. He made a huge fuss about having no time and being far too busy, so I did most of it. His main concern was what to do with the cash when the house was sold. Mum may have expensive care needs in the future and also has a very cautious approach to money, so I have taken a conservative approach.

He, on the other hand, wanted to access most of it to start a new enterprise, which involved tying money up in property and included him being 'compensated' for his time. He wasn't interested in what I thought, brushed aside my questions & objections, shouted at me several times, and refused to even consider that my mum didn't want to do this. She froze. I booked a meeting with a financial advisor to move things on a bit and he ruined the meeting by ignoring the advice, pressing his idea, and continued to press the idea after the advisor had left. My mum was so distressed she couldn't speak or look at anyone. I ended up leaving. Eventually, a relative spoke to him and he gave up his idea.

He behaves as if nothing has happened. Twin has been able to use the incident against me (not sure what has been said but there is some definite frostiness with other family). He knows I am furious with him because I told him how upset my mum was and that this awful episode has also made me ill. So since February we have been virtually no contact and his wife has also told me not to contact her because I told her we needed to acknowledge what had happened before we could move on.

He has just turned up on my doorstep with no warning, with his children and some Easter eggs for me and my teens, all smiles, no hint of apology or 'peace-making'. I didn't have any eggs for them so that was disappointing for his young children. Now he can tell everyone he came to my house with Easter eggs and I was rude and that his children were disappointed that I didn't have anything for them. I don't care about him any more but I do care about my nephews.

What do I do?

OP posts:
LuluJakey1 · 23/04/2014 22:43

I have POA for an elderly Uncle. If I remember, there were two types- financial and personal- and he named me in the legal document as having both if that time came where he could not make decisions himself. At that point the POA had to be invoked to actually give me the power to take responsibility for his finances and personal affairs. Once that was done and I had the POA signed and stamped documents back, I had total control and he could not then make those decisions (not that he wanted to as he has vascular dementia, but the point being the POA moved that power entirely across to me). When he discussed it with me and asked me if I was prepared to do it, I wanted there to be two of us so it was open and accountable and another cousin agreed to be named too. We can make decisions alone if the other one is unavailable but not huge decisions. It has never amounted to much as the care home fees are paid by direct debit and I just make sure he has toiletries and clothes and pocket money- which is rarely spent.

My point is, if you have been named as having financial and personal POA for your mum and the legal status of it has been invoked, your brother can not bypass you because your mum has given you the power legally. He can try to persuade her as much as he likes but the POA is there to protect her from making bad decisions/ being ressured into decisions - because she is vulnerable.

LuluJakey1 · 23/04/2014 22:45

pressured, not ressured! Sorry.

DeckSwabber · 25/04/2014 14:03

Well that could have gone worse, but could have been better.

It took the first half hour to be able to say anything without him interrupting. I thought afterward that maybe he's terrified of what I might say if I'm allowed to speak.

He says he regards the issue over the property plan as 'miniscule' and thinks I am making something of nothing, and its all my fault anyway if it did cause distress, because I 'wouldn't listen' to his plan in the first place.

I learned some of the things my mum says to him about me , eg apparently I don't keep her (or anybody) in touch with whats happening, but also 'she keeps coming round and I don't know why' [note to mum: those would be all the times I drive a 200 mile round trip to make sure you know exactly what's happening]. Frustrating, but I'm not surprised to hear this.

He got through the meeting without offering to help at all and ended it by telling me I should go to therapy with him to address my issues.

But steps forward-

  • he seemed to register in the end that I wasn't actually making it up that my mum is distressed.
  • he says he wants to meet again to carry on.
  • he says he will back me up more with my mum.
OP posts:
frostyfingers · 25/04/2014 14:48

You are in a nightmare of a situation and I can't really think of what to say that might help. My only observation is that my mother has stroke induced dementia, my sister and I have POA, and she frequently berates us for "stealing her money", "making it so I've got no control", "not telling her what's going on", etc etc so however hard that aspect is try not to take it personally.

It's very very hard when you know you are doing your absolute best to help and it either gets thrown back in your face or sneered at by others.

AttilaTheMeerkat · 25/04/2014 14:53

"He got through the meeting without offering to help at all and ended it by telling me I should go to therapy with him to address my issues".

No, just no!. BTW what was your response to that "request" of his?.

"But steps forward-

  • he seemed to register in the end that I wasn't actually making it up that my mum is distressed.

Well even he could have worked that one out in the end.

"- he says he wants to meet again to carry on.

  • he says he will back me up more with my mum".

He may well decide to meet again to further verbally berate
you. Whether he will actually back you up more with regards to your mother is still debateable; that will depend on how good he would look out of doing so.

DeckSwabber · 25/04/2014 15:09

Attila, how he looks and appears to others is obviously important to him. He only really started to listen when I pointed out that Aunt was appalled at his behaviour. Until that point he's been pretty confident that everyone thinks he's lovely.

And no, absolutely no way would I go to therapy with him. I just said no, it wasn't my priority and that I am content to accept that we were different and don't particularly get on. I think it really bothers him that I don't like him, but he will not accept that he could be responsible for how I feel.

Frosty these accusations are horrible but I can cope with it because I know I'm not ripping her off and that she's afraid and ill. The bit I struggle with is that she doesn't get the reassurance she needs.

Funny I've just remembered that he said that my mum has repeatedly told him that I haven't got time to help her, yet he never once offered to help me.

OP posts:
DeckSwabber · 25/04/2014 19:21

Spoke to my mums GP. It's looking like a dementia diagnosis. I've also explained to the GP about the situation with Twin (who won't 'let' me attend medical appointments).

A trying day. But perhaps some progress.

I hope my brother is thinking about what I've said.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page