Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Would you want your DD to visit an Alcoholic GP?

10 replies

Rocklover · 19/07/2006 14:00

Hi all, would appreciate opinions on this.

My FIL is an alcoholic who beats his wife, last incident was over the New Year and has been quiet since then. I don't visit anymore after March 2005 when FIL fought with DH in the same room my DD was (then 3 months) asleep! DH is still being civil to his Dad (after a fall out last year) and wants to visit them next week as his school holidays start, only now he wants me to start visiting again (despite the fact they will never visit us whilst we are staying with my parents).

So I agreed to go, mug that I am, however yesterday DH's brother called to let him know that his Mum wants to leave FIL (again; she does this regularly, then decides it's too much hassle, I used to be sympathetic, but that has run out!!). The reason for this is that FIL is drinking heavily again, DH wasn't supposed to know as his Mum doesn't want to be pressured by DH into leaving (he told her last time, that if she chooses to go back to FIL he would not be helping her next time, sounds mean, but he was trying to shock her into leaving...didn't work).

The upshot of this is I really don't think any of us should go next week whilst FIL is having one of his 'episodes', especially as I haven't spoken to him in at least a year and he knows I can't stand him, I am sure this would make things worse. My main worry is that I don't EVER want my baby (now 18 months) to be exposed to drinking and violence (I was scared at 30 yrs old), DH agrees, but still will not cancel, has now said "we'll see what happens over the week, then decide".

If I had my way DD would never even be in the same town as my FIL, do you think that I am being over-protective? DH used to be as horrified as me, but now is fed up with my views as he feels that I am too critical and that "he is my Dad after all". I do understand most people love their parents no matter what, but I just don't want my DD involved. All opinions welcomed!!!

OP posts:
NotQuiteCockney · 19/07/2006 14:06

I would not have my kids around someone who was drinking seriously, never mind violent. (DS1, recently, at over 4, had his first encounter with a drunk person (random drunk guy in the market).

If your DH wants to go see his parents, that's fair enough, but you and your DD shouldn't have to go.

edam · 19/07/2006 14:06

I thought you were talking about an alcoholic doctor.

Really hard one - is there anyway of knowing in advance whether he'll be drunk or not? Agree with you that you cannot have your children somewhere where it could turn violent. Sympathise with dh to some extent that this guy is his dad, but there's nothing to stop dh visiting him on his own.

expatinscotland · 19/07/2006 14:08

I wouldn't want my daughter around that, either. Your DH can go alone. But if FIL flies off the handle, it could really effect your DD for a long, long time.

NotQuiteCockney · 19/07/2006 14:10

I would recommend your DH either go to counselling, or you guys go to Relate, or he talks to Alanon about this, as him arging you must go (and bring DD) is bonkers, frankly.

FioFio · 19/07/2006 14:13

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

eenywifemum · 19/07/2006 14:13

I agree with everyone else. Your FIL is unpredictable and you and your DD shouldnt have to go. He may be your husbands Dad but that doesnt entitle him to potentially traumatise your DD.

eenywifemum · 19/07/2006 14:14

BTW I thought it was about an alcoholic doctor too!

Piffle · 19/07/2006 14:15

You're being sensible, reasonable and perfectly responsible
Your DH is an adult and can choose to visit when he likes. Let him visit, report back and go from there. But while FIL is in a heay drinking period and is prone to violent outbursts, without question you should stay away. If you feel under threat crikey...

People who are prone to those kinds of outbursts rarely have any control about who they lash out at either...

Rocklover · 19/07/2006 14:58

Oops, GP thing didn't occur to me lol! What an idiot!

OP posts:
SSSandy · 19/07/2006 15:10

Wouldn't ever take dd over there but wouldn't stand in the way of DH visiting his parents or offer any criticism of them. The result would be of course that they would think very badly of me but I could live with that. (No way would I visit a man who beats his wife anyway).

New posts on this thread. Refresh page