Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

how do i get il's to help out at Christmas without causing offence?

33 replies

justmuckinwillyou · 19/11/2013 20:27

my il's are pretty good really. nice and kind, but are probably quite self-centred if i'm honest. mil is really amazing, but she is elderly and i want her to have a relaxing Christmas and not have to worry about a thing.

my bil and sil come to visit about once a month and stay with mil, but come to ours for most meals so that mil doesn't have to cook / shop. happy to do this. we enjoy their company and they are the only family our kids see regularly. we get invited back once a year on average. also fine. we are quite a handful.

sil has asked what they can contribute for Christmas this year. They (bil, sil and mil) are staying for two days. she's thinking pudding / crackers but what i would really appreciate is just helping with the work load! help clear the table, clear up their stuff, make a cup of tea. this is what i do when i go to theirs. when i have asked them to help in the past it's been very half-hearted and short-lived.

so just for once given that she's asked, i'd like them to give me a bit of a hand.

how can i word it without causing issues and making them feel like this is what i'm always thinking (true Blush)? i really don't want to cause any ill feeling. i'd actually rather they came and did nothing than not come at all.

so is it better to:

a) ask up front for a bit of help. maybe defined tasks that i can pretend are fun (setting table).

b) ask for help on the day.

c) just tell dh to sort his family out. (i will be strongly implicated. i know this from bitter experience.)

d) just suck it up

e) drink a bottle of gin and pass out.

OP posts:
MrsHoratioNelson · 20/11/2013 14:28

I think you need to be specific and forthright - "SIL can you peel the carrots please?" It's very difficult to say no to a specific request like that and all to easy to let people wait to ask "is there anything I can do?" usually just as you're plating up when it's too bloody late

FaceDirectionOfTravel · 20/11/2013 14:45

Need to come back to this. Have this same issue with certain members of the family (and the opposite issue with some people who will not sit down and relax)!

In the past I have just asked if they can be totally responsible for a whole meal (Boxing Day breakfast is a good one), and then have asked people by name to help with a specific task like loading the dishwasher. If they start to drift off thinking it is done I find new things for them to put in until they get the idea. People are extraordinary, aren't they.

capsium · 20/11/2013 14:58

Wine helps I find.

FaceDirectionOfTravel · 20/11/2013 16:04

See, if I have wine I get real honest, real fast and start making 'comments'. Bad for harmonious family events and in fact most relationships I find!

capsium · 20/11/2013 16:17

Oh I stop caring too much about the clearing up and cooking and get sort of jolly with a bit of wine. Not too much though, otherwise dinner might be compromised.

justmuckinwillyou · 20/11/2013 17:12

ok i have a plan:

  1. assign tasks to sil beforehand when the topic of contribution comes up next.
  1. assume that those tasks will be completed without fuss or forgetfulness on bil&sil's part and will not manage the process as i am known and expected to do. they are adults and if i wish them to act as such i must give them opportunity to step up to plate etc.
  1. will categorically NOT get up from table after Christmas lunch but will slide under it together with the eggnog.
  1. will wave airily at kitchen cupboards when asked for tea / coffee / hot chocolate made with full cream hot milk.
  1. spend the rest of the time with the kids enjoying their company at Christmas for once.
  1. studiously ignore pigsty of a house and just worry about it once they've all gone. with any luck they'll survey the carnage with horror and straighten up a bit in case i've lost the plot.

and i agree with all of you - who in their right minds thinks it's ok to leave all the work to one person all the time(ok ok dh helps a bit)?

OP posts:
Blu · 20/11/2013 17:37

"and i agree with all of you - who in their right minds thinks it's ok to leave all the work to one person all the time(ok ok dh helps a bit)?"

No-one! Remember the furore about the Asda advert last year where women were supposed to laugh indulgently at a man on a sofa asking for a cup of tea after we had seen the woman slaving all Christmas Day long?

I turn up at my DB and SILs with my Marigolds, no-one assumes that it is all anything other than a group effort - and that makes it fun.

CharlieAlphaKiloEcho · 20/11/2013 17:40

Your plan sounds good.

I was going to suggest a broken toe or badly sprained ankle just before they arrive but definitely stick to your plan instead :)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page