Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

DS being treated differently to the other GC in the family. (Long)

28 replies

QuizzicalCat · 10/01/2013 22:50

I have NC for this.

DS is 5 and the youngest of six GC. He's a lovely little chap, happy, polite, generally well behaved etc. (Not me being PFB - I know I'm lucky - just hoping I'll be as lucky when he hits his teens is anyone that lucky?!).

I have often wondered if he is treated differently to the other GC in the family and having recently spent Christmas with the ILs I think he really is.

The other GC got two or three quite expensive Christmas presents each from the GP - DS got one joint present from the ILs - all of them, DHs two brothers and his parents. It's a nice present, admittedly, but cost the same as one of the presents the others got, and they also got seperate presents from their Uncles.

I know Christmas isn't about money, but when a child gets one present to everyone else getting five I just think it's unfair - it's not about monetary value - he doesn't see money, he sees parcels. Particularly as we were at the GPs for Christmas and he got to see the others presents and hear them say "This one is from Granny and Grampsy, and this one is from Uncle X and Auntie XX, and this one was from Granny and Grampsy too."

For his birthday DS got a £10 note in his card - nice to have a present - but the other GC got actual parcels, in the plural. And again, costing significantly more (by significantly I mean £50-£60 each).

In addition the GP often buy all the GC (except DS) books or pyjamas or whatever and say they will do the same for DS, but then nothing ever materialises. So many things have been promised over the years and not appeared. When I was pregnant with DS DH and I made a list of the things we needed to buy, and various family members offered to buy us things, including the ILs who even discussed specific brands and colours of the items etc with us. We then didn't buy or budget for those things which was unfortunate as we then had to buy them ourselves as they never materialised, and after the indepth discussions over a number of days involving the ILs doing a ton of research and bringing information round, were never mentioned again. This has happened more than once in the last five years, but after the first instance I haven't expected to get the things they say they are buying us - and so far I've been right. On the flip side the GPs bought quite a lot of the baby equipment for DH's brothers children and regularly buy bits for the other GC.

Until Christmas this year DS was too young to really notice the difference, but now he is starting to pick up on it. He does spend time with the ILs, and they are good with him when he is there, but when he comes home saying "Granny and Grampsy said they will buy me X,Y,Z" and it doesn't appear he doesn't really understand why. He has also asked me why cousin A got such and such a thing from Granny and Grampsy and he didn't.

At some point he is going to notice just how differently they treat him compared to his cousins, and he is potentially going to be really hurt by it. I am not sure why they do this, other than they treat DH differently to his brothers (they still get presents from their parents for Christmas and birthdays - DH hasn't got anything in years - not even a card, and it hurts him more than he would ever admit to).

I don't want DS to go through the same hurt as DH - what on earth can I do about it though? DS has a good relationship with his GPs and wider family, he loves them and likes seeing them and we want to maintain the relationships, but now he is starting to pick up on the fact that he is treated differently. At the moment he isn't really old enough to realise that he's being treated differently in a negative way, but he will do soon enough, and I want to try to do something so that it's sorted before he is able to understand and be hurt by it.

What would you do?

Thanks if you got this far - it's a little epic, but I've been sitting on it for nearly six years.

OP posts:
moajab · 11/01/2013 11:30

I feel really sad for your DS and DH. I really would not buy Christmas presents for your DNieces and nephews. I know it seems mean, but they are already getting more than your DS, so not buying for them but buying a few more for your DS would even it out. Not bringing presents to birthday party is very rude. This sounds like a conspiracy if the brothers their wives and their parents are all acting the same. In my DHs family I'm fairly certain the favourtism is more subconscious, but for your DH it sounds more like deliberate meaness.

Your DS may love his cousins, but he would no probably get on well with other children jusr as well. Do you have friends with DC his age you can see at weekends?

Astelia · 11/01/2013 11:41

This is so sad and I can't understand how any GP would act in this way. I don't think you and DH have got anything to lose in asking them why they behave as they do and to ask them to treat all the GC the same. Then it is down to them how they respond.

With the DBIL and DSIL talk to them in a few months time about Christmas and birthday presents and suggest you don't want to exchange presents any more as or be brave and say because you don't buy anything for DS.

boschy · 11/01/2013 14:06

Hi OP, we are a good few years ahead of you on the GP having favourites front - my DDs are now 16 and nearly 14. I also have the DH who has his own family (ie us) and SIL, whose ex walked out about 6 years ago and spends most w/e at PIL with her 2 children whose ages are close to mine.

DH was the 'naughty' boy and SIL the 'good' girl and this scenario has been replayed by PIL in terms of how they see our children. DH is another who doesnt want to talk about it...

All I can say is that the children very soon see through what the GPs are doing, and in our case it has led to a significantly less close relationship for the GPs with our DDs. The DDs - and I - see it as "their loss" quite frankly, and I am afraid I have managed their expectations in relation to their GPs - eg cousins get taken to lunch and theatre; DDs dont. They dont seem bothered - but they couldnt care less whether they see GPs or not.

Luckily for them they are very close to my mum, so they do have a 'good' grandma.

I'm sorry, it is a horrible situation to be in.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page