Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Is my brother-in-law abusive?

6 replies

hohummm · 04/04/2011 21:33

Sorry this is quite long..

My sister is married with grown up children - youngest is now 16.
He is her husband's and she has two other children from a previous relationship.
She met her husband when her two oldest were very small but he has never been interested in them and many years ago now my sister, her husband and youngest child moved abroad because of his job.

They have moved around a lot since and taken the youngest with them but the other two children who are not his have been raised by my mother. They never got a say in whether they moved abroad or not and rightfully feel very hurt that their mum has essentially chosen her husband over them. This has created a lot of resentment which my sister does not seem to understand at all.

My family have grown further and further apart from my sister because of this and because her husband does not seem to like us around. For example if we go and visit them instead of spending time with us, he has her constantly running errands for him which makes it impossible for us to do anything together. If we ever go out anywhere we have to cut the trip short so she can be home to make lunch/dinner for him, wash his clothes, collect something he has bought from a shop, go and collect papers from his office etc etc so we feel like we have no real quality time with her.

They have separate bank accounts and my sister struggles to pay for all of the bills and food from her part time job while he has thousands in the bank and spends a good proportion of it on new cars every few months, new surround sound systems, whatever he likes.

Last year there was a big family wedding and my sister promised she would be there, said how much she was looking forward to it. It got nearer the time and she told us she wouldn't be able to make it because she couldn't afford it. Her husband knew how much it meant to her and could easily have afforded to buy her a plane ticket but didn't.

I am also fairly sure he is an alcoholic albeit a functioning one. He manages to hold down well paid jobs and doesn't drink every day but when he does he can't stop and I have heard stories of my nephews and niece being on the receiving end of some very nasty comments when he has had too much to drink.

We speak a lot on the phone and skype but it often ends with my sister in tears because she says she misses her family so much and wishes she could be here with us.

So my question is, is her husband just an arsehole or is this abuse?
We have told her so many times to leave him and she always says the next time he moves (he gets bored every few years or so and will move hundreds of miles away and start again) that she will not be going but she always follows him.

What else can I do that I haven't already? Do I just need to accept this is how it's always going to be?

OP posts:
doormat · 04/04/2011 21:40

sounds like emotional and economic abuse to me...he is a wankstain

i would just continue to support your sister and let her know you are still there whenever she needs you

hohummm · 04/04/2011 21:44

We just do not understand why she stays. If she decided to move back here anyone in our family would take her in while she got back on her feet.

He is not even a very nice man, why does she put up with this when she won't take crap from anyone else? In all other aspects she is a very strong woman but when it comes to this man she is completely under his thumb, it upsets my mother so much.

OP posts:
FabbyChic · 04/04/2011 22:21

Why is she paying all the bills? What does he contribute? Seems to me she made a rod for her own back pandying to his every whim all the time. She has been the doormat and he has wipped his feet on her.

Katisha · 04/04/2011 22:31

Get her the Lundy Bancroft book?

doormat · 05/04/2011 05:22

hohum..i can imagine your mother is upset and the rest of your family is fuming and i cant answer why she stays but your sister is obviously suffering from forms of domestic abuse...she needs your support for the day she finally wakes up and smells the coffee, which i am positive will be there from you and your family...

like katisha says maybe an empowerment book might help

hugs (((())))

PeterAndreForPM · 05/04/2011 08:41

There is nothing you can do except make it clear you are there for her, should she ever decide she can take no more

It must always be possible for her to leave without losing face, because often in these situations the abused person does not like to admit they were wrong all along and everyone else was right

I am sorry for her, and for you you to have to stand by and watch the car crash Sad

New posts on this thread. Refresh page