Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Am I alone in regretting having moved last year and want to move back?

40 replies

wahwah1270 · 14/04/2009 11:34

Last spring when pregnant with dd we moved from zone 2 london to rural essex . whilst we areonly a commuter train ride from london i constantly pine for my normality - i was there for 17 years. DH and ihave discussed this and his view is that we could only do it in x years when i'm working again etc but i feel for my sanity i need to move back sooner, all my friends are in london . how can i convince dh we should move sooner than later.

OP posts:
MrsMattie · 16/04/2009 14:13

Come back to London!

To be honest, I have never understood the rural ideal. Don't most young people move to towns or cities to go to university/work eventually, anyway?

Sorry, I am completely and utterly biased as I love London, but look - the country is nice for a day trip. You can go back anytime if you want to look at cows and sheep and coo at the quaint little cottages.

Seriously, though - prices are definitely lower here than they've been in a very long time. Maybe you could rent for a bit and see how you feel?

noddyholder · 16/04/2009 15:06

oh mrsmattie don't say that and get me all confused again!I am not allowed back to London for at least 5 yrs by which time it will prob be astronomical again

MrsMattie · 16/04/2009 15:19

Sorry

I am London's biggest cheerleader. Don't listen to me. i am just a stark raving mad woman with pom poms and a stupidly short skirt on, paying silly amounts of money for a poky house that i could get for about a 10th of the price anywhere else on earth!

Anyway, just think of the millons of rats and the rush hour and the litter and the crime and the annoying cock-er-nees like me...

noddyholder · 16/04/2009 15:25

I am right behind you, doesn't go down well at parties where I live now though.

francagoestohollywood · 16/04/2009 15:27

I've never understood the rural idyl as well. I moved from a big city to a small city in the middle of devon (which appears to be a very desirable place for most) 10 yrs ago and never got used to it.

And btw, I'd move to London tomorrow if we could.

lalalonglegs · 16/04/2009 16:40

Yeah, having children and living in London is seen as tantamount to child abuse by some. Can never understand the appeal of the country - full of smells and nosiness in my experience.

perma · 21/04/2009 09:17

This happened to my neighbour - they realised immediately that they had made a mistake - they had been in centre of our small city before and could walk everywhere, then moved to a pretty hamlet only 15 or so mins outside (much longer at busy times of day) spent all their time driving everywhere, hated it and put house on market 2 weeks later. Was a lot of upheaval but they are back in town and happier than ever. (I think they may have had a very idealised view of country life - she thought it would be all agas, apple cheeked children in Cath Kidston dresses and people popping in and out with fairy cakes, but in fact was just normal people getting on with their normal lives). In their case they just knew it was wrong, but obv depending on your exact circs perhaps time will make you feel different. If you know it is totally wrong then I'd hold up your hands and move back now. Poor you - hope you sort it out soon.

izyboy · 21/04/2009 18:19

mm yeah.. it's a difficult one. I have never lived in London, but moved to a village on the outskirts of a capital city.

I would prefer to live in a trendy, nice part of the city than where I do now. But would prefer to live where I am than a 'gritty' really urban part of the inner city.

It can be very boring and isolating with kids in a rural setting. No shops to walk to, no kids' facilities on the doorstep...you have to drive everywhere... a bit depressing for sure.

Fimbo · 28/04/2009 17:43

I know how you feel. We moved to England nearly 9 years ago because of my dh's job. I hate it, it is not my home, just somewhere I live.

I yearn to move back to Scotland but there are no jobs in my dh's field.

Or I would love to move to Greenwich but that is hopeless too.

Nisanoise · 19/01/2020 22:20

Hi there! My DH, my 2 sons and 3 cats, moved from a very well located and nice Appaertment in the area Poblenou, Barcelona, to a house in a village with a huge garden and a basketball area. Outside is BIG! Inside very small...

Our flat in Poblenou (really nice area in Barcelona I highly recommend you to visit) was refurbished, brand new kitchen and bath, Parket floor, ceramic tiles in the kitchen, we choose the materials and contracted a very professional bricklayer and plumber. The flat was nice, the sun day caming in the leaving room, located 15 min walking to the beach, even if we weren't going often, we could feel the breeze from the sea in our rooms...just beautiful.

Nevertheless, was not everything positive, kids room had not so much natural light, my partner couldn't work with wood as he had not a workshop to build stuff, and the bad smell wafting up from the cat litter was unbearable. My dear husband was complaining every day about the impact noise pollution and contamination was having on him. He grow up in France until he was 11 then he moved to the UK where he spent more than 20 years, living mainly in the country side. Having a house with garden in the UK, is a pretty normal thing that almost everyone can afford. Whilst here in Barcelona, being able to afford the Gadren is something only rich people can do, unless you move to a village.

In the apartment we had in Barcelona, I was feeling happy, shops were close, supermarkets also, we had 15 minutes walk to the beach, and we didn't need to look up in the web for plans very often, as there were thousands of events nearby. Working in the street there, was very different as it is here. There, you were anonymous, whilst here in the village, almost everybody knows you, you see everyday the same faces, which wouldn't be a problem if they would be more open minded, but that's not the case...

Having leaved in Barcelona for a long time, having interacted with people from all around the world, with different point of views, different mentalities, backgrouns and different goals, it feels a bit difficult to adapt here, where most of them have only one or two nationalities, and a narrow perspective of life. Being negative or pessimistic about "village life" is very bad viewed in a village,
they idealise it here, and are not open for seeing different points of view.

After more than 1 year complaints from my DH about noise and pollution in the city, about the cat's litter smell in the flat and the stress behavior he had towards our big son (DH justified it saying is bcuz they don't have a garden they shout so loud and he gets stressed) I decided following his desire to go out of the city and moving to a house with garden, parking place and a workshop. This took me more than one year to decide since we first planned about moving out the city, as I was scared about how could I manage living in the country side without a car, far away from people and shops, and being dependent of a bus that passes every 3 hours. Now I understand all this fears...life here is not what I'm used to, I'm out of my comfort zone and find it difficult to relax here and find joy. It is paradoxal, as it would make more sense to feel relaxed in a quite place like that then in an apartment in the city, but this is not the case... I feel here less vitality and energy (even if the quality of the air is better here) and I'm suffering from anxiety and episodes of depression since we moved here. Sometimes I think, this won't happen to me if I would be more skilled in DIY, kneeting, and things like that, but even this I prefer to do it with people than alone. I'm 36, still dreaming on going to the Uni, or having my own business in a crowded place, I love to see people, and know that there are human beings walking anytime in the streets next to my flat, I'm not such a fan of nature, animals and silence, I rather prefer the interaction with people anytime I want it, not just when the bus schedule wants it.

My DH has a very demanding job, which envolves daily meetings that require preparation so he needs to be in a quite place like that. He hates being inside and loves being outside, moving, building, stretching his arms without restrictions, he feels free here, and would feel very happy if it was bcuz of my daily complaints about the opposite feelings I have about it.

We both are lacking vitality, he looks older than before because of me feeling miserable all he time here. I want to feel better here but not sure if I can. Need to find a job first and then see...but I'm scared about picking up the children on time once working so far from the village. Well maybe it's not the distance what concerns me, but the bus schedules. Even if it takes 10 min. with the car, with a bus that passes every 3 hours, is a different history...

Maybe I should focus on the driving license before looking for a job. I don't know why we humans complicate life so much, I would love to be less scared and more positive thinker.

"Urban people or village people", does that really exist or is an invention of our brains? Getting out of your comfort zone is tricky but maybe helps us to grow and mature. What do you think?

Nisanoise · 19/01/2020 22:33

Instead of "working in the street" I meant "walking in the street" ...

madcatladyforever · 19/01/2020 22:49

No, I've gone from rural to even more deep rural, I'd wither and die in a city.

Hawkmoth · 19/01/2020 22:59

Urban sprawl to rural village last year. I don't think I could ever go back. I'd take physical freedom over commercial freedom every day.

Dark skies and fresh air, very restorative.

FrownsAndDimples · 19/01/2020 23:15

This is a 2009 thread. Wonder why the OP did?

Nisanoise · 20/01/2020 08:15

I am personally more free in the city than here in the village, I lack motivation for almost everything here, I wake up, do kids breakfast and then want to go back to bed after they,ve jumped in the car to go to school. My partner is the opposite he feels very happy waking up everyday with those views.
I don't even find motivation to look for jobs, I feel like empty and can't enjoy things I used to enjoy.

I idealise renting a flat in Calella (the closest crowded place here) only for me and try a relationship were both live separated, as his needs are opposite as mines. Why we women have to sacrifice always so much? I understand he works hard and needs peace of mind, quite place to live in, but I'm the opposite, need noise and people, need movement, need inspiration, and the town gives me that, and makes me feel physically free knowing I can jump in the train and be in the centre of bcn whenever I want it, without depending on a bus, that passes every 3 hours.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page