OK - I am originally from Redcar and lived down south for 12 years, but have returned back to the area with my children.
I now live in a village between Redcar and Whitby.
Goathland is lovley - You would get snowed in maybe. Very small village and you would have to travel for most things, but there are some lovley pleaces to visit nearby. We chose to live on the baten track adn visit loads of places.
Saltburn is a great beach for the children, valley gardens, small train, surfing, pier, childrens centre, lovley toddlers, leuisre centre etc
Although from Redcar it isnt were I would want to live, although fine to visit mum and bro and SIL
Whitby is 20 mins for us and it great in the summer, but awful in the winter. DH worked there for 4 years and it is a strange, but wonderful place.
Where would you be working, as that would really depend on living.
Stocksley is lovley, Saltburn is a good area.