Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Unreasonable to renegotiate after a survey?

52 replies

foursquares · 04/10/2026 23:44

Property originally listed last year (2025) for £520k. Reduced to £475k, didn't sell. On market for 6 months.

Reslisted this year for £450k. One offer in first week, no other offers apart from mine (accepted £435k in 4th month).

I've had a building survey done and needs a new roof (costs £20k approx from roofer and other £5k works).

Seller not budging on price, as he think he's already reduced significantly, so Aibu to expect negotiation on price?

OP posts:
BraOffPjsOn · 09/10/2026 07:46

KatiePricesKnickers · 08/10/2026 10:04

Ah ok, along with the other issues then best to pull out.
If it was only the roof, then at least you would end up benefiting from a new roof on an old house, even if you couldn’t secure a further discount.
There are tens of thousands of old houses that will need a new roof, it’s just a game of musical chairs who gets the pleasure of paying for one. Clay tiles don’t last forever and once the frost gets them, their demise is accelerated.

But this is only if you can afford a new roof if the house price wasn’t hiked up.
We can’t afford a new roof as we’re already paying top price for this house, without roof issues.
If the sellers haven’t maintained it at all over all their years, why do they feel it would be the buyers responsibility to take it on?

I am genuinely asking as I feel like this kind of thing is seen in two completely different lights.

KatiePricesKnickers · 09/10/2026 08:19

BraOffPjsOn · 09/10/2026 07:46

But this is only if you can afford a new roof if the house price wasn’t hiked up.
We can’t afford a new roof as we’re already paying top price for this house, without roof issues.
If the sellers haven’t maintained it at all over all their years, why do they feel it would be the buyers responsibility to take it on?

I am genuinely asking as I feel like this kind of thing is seen in two completely different lights.

If it’s the perfect house for you and you can afford a new roof and you are going to live there for sometime, it can make sense.
When you come to sell it, you won’t need to give a discount for roof repairs and it’s more salable than one without a new roof.

There are not many decent houses out there.
I fully agree that owners who don’t maintain their properties (my FiL for instance) shouldn’t expect top dollar, but it’s not a perfect world.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page