Quartz, quartzite, granite, laminate ..advice please re kitchen worktops!

[Sidebeforeself]

2 years ago moved into a flat with white laminate worktops. Despite being careful the laminate is already lifting in the heavy duty areas . It is also stained. I need to replace in the next year I think but prices mean I’ll have to start saving now. My kitchen isn’t large but theres some cutting involved.

My issue because of the lack of light in the kitchen I’d prefer a light worktop therefore I know Im risking staining.

So which is best for durability and cost?
I had laminate before in my old flat and that held up really well ,but it was dark grey.
Laminate is too easy to chip I think.
Got quotes for quartz and quartzite and it came in at around £5k for both which is about £1k more than I can afford really.

Just looking for ideas and experiences. ..if you have light laminate do you retreat it etc?

£5k sounds very high for quartz. We have a relatively large kitchen and got quartz from al-Murad (including templating and installation) for a lot less than that!

Following as we are replacing kitchen and can't decide on worktops. Are there any good options?

I'm very put off quartz due to it being banned in Australia and other countries investigating concerns about effect of silica on workers.

Had wood in the past and it does not work for us as people don't wipe up water in our house and I don't want the maintenance. Same with granite or other stone.

Definitely don't want to replace laminated chipboard with more laminated chipboard.

Compact laminate has poor reviews and I didn't like the samples I got.

Formica laminated plywood looks nice buy I don't think we'd do well keeping the edges dry enough, that's what we're having for our doors.

This pretty much leaves stainless steel or Corian.

I prefer the idea of stainless steel although people say it scratches and shows up fingerprints. We've had a sample of matt sanded stainless steel for worktops and we like it, although we wonder if the fact that it's sanded might make it more susceptible to corrosion than a satin.

We've had a quote for just over £3000 for Corian, waiting for samples, just not sure I'll love it. But cheaper than stainless steel unless we install that ourselves.

Keen to hear what people here suggest.

We had quartz fitted last year for approx £3k (good size kitchen). Within 2 weeks I knocknet a small spice jar from a cupboard and it chipped the edge. Not impressed! However it looks really good and i couldn’t find an alternative worktop. I had laminate before and it lasted really well (12 years) brfore it chipped

Never heard of Al Murad and I’m in Yorkshire so thanks @Kwamitiki
I was looking at Corian too. @Netcam what do you mean by maintenance? There’s only two of us and I’m a bit obsessed with wiping up … or does it need something else?

Do you mean maintenance of wood, granite or stone? They all need regular oiling/sealing. Our wood worktops looked lovely but they were too much work to keep in good condition, especially by the sink.

Have you looked at high pressure porcelain? It's low silica so not the same risks to workers s quartz. heat- and scratch-resistant. Like this: https://www.ikea.com/gb/en/p/moecklarp-custom-made-worktop-matt-off-white-marble-effect-high-pressure-porcelain-10603929/

We have granite (Labrador antique granite - it’s mostly brown with some blue-green labradorite crystals, which catch the light beautifully). We’ve had it for years and have completely neglected it, absolutely no special treatment at all, no post-installation sealing or special cleaning or polishing or oiling or whatever you’re supposed to do. We have a cluttered work surface with regular puddles of water by the sink. It still looks absolutely pristine. Hasn’t ever chipped, no stains, marks, nothing.

We went around a massive “granite, marble etc” warehouse to choose the slab. It was much much cheaper than the kitchen showroom “quartz” type costs. It doesn’t feel dark as it’s so shiny and reflective, and the colours are quite soft. The pic that will eventually load is just a random website pic but our kitchen is similar colours - it would have looked nice with a wooden worktop but we know from experience we would absolutely destroy that. Granite is very durable.

If you knock the edge of quartz it will chip.

You can google quartz worktop chip repair if you want to get a kit to repair it or get a professional in.

Not read full thread but I really love our Corian work surfaces. They must be 15 years old now and are still in fantastic condition - really easy to wipe clean. Love the sink particularly - that has a stainlesss steel base but the sides are corian too so it’s all seamless with no ridges for dirt to build up in.

Meant to addd - ours is a pale colour with speckles and no issue with staining or marks. Only downside is the price (it’s not cheap!)

Have a look on YouTube for kitchinsider. He has a series of videos about choosing materials for a kitchen, and one is a very informative piece on worktops, including, maintenance and durability.

We have a light coloured quartz - which I love. Maintenance free. Clean with anything apart from vinegar (acid).

I found it difficult to choose between quartz and formica as there are lovely formica worktops available now.

We’ve got a white slightly marbles quartz worktop. Got it apx 6 years ago and think it was £3k plus vat all in (templating and installation) for the worktop and a decent sized island). It is easy to keep clean and anything that stains (like squished blueberries… we have a toddler!) can be cleaned easily with bar keepers friend.

I’m having my kitchen redone and have chosen a good quality laminate. The laminate worktops I have just now have been pretty bomb proof and I’m not prepared to spend thousands on something that chips or needs careful maintenance - it’s a working kitchen so functionality beats style for me.

Think they cover nationwide (we are Sussex). Gemini (i didn't like them as I found the sales tactics aggressive), Purple Granite and Natural Stone Surfaces also come.up a fair bit when talking about worktops.

We have granite (Labrador antique granite - it’s mostly brown with some blue-green labradorite crystals, which catch the light beautifully). We’ve had it for years and have completely neglected it, absolutely no special treatment at all, no post-installation sealing or special cleaning or polishing or oiling or whatever you’re supposed to do. We have a cluttered work surface with regular puddles of water by the sink. It still looks absolutely pristine. Hasn’t ever chipped, no stains, marks, nothing.

This is also my experience (except granite is grey with some purple crystals). I've never sealed it, oiled it or anything. 10 years later is is still perfect and gorgeous.

I got a quartz worktop & installation in 2021 for about half your quoted price from GMT stones. It included upstands and a splashback (small kitchen).

It’s super low maintenance and still looks in mint condition, it’s added value to my place according to agents.

Thanks I’ll take a look

we also have granite, also never done anything with it. its never stained. a couple of tiny chips that the average eye can't see. been in 13 years.

ours is a blue and grey fleck. probably too dark for you.

maybe look at lighter granites?