House one is better decor wise, seems a quieter road and according to the square footage is a bit bigger than house 2? They’re both in pretty much the same location so it can’t be that.
They’re both only thing that house 2 potentially has over house 1 is the separate dining room. Which can either be left as a separate room or knocked through to make a full width kitchen diner.
saying that with house one you could make the living room smaller and then make a full width kitchen, diner. At the moment from looking at the floor plan the rear of the living room seems like wasted space to me.