Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Survey Advice - Negotiate on roof?

4 replies

RealOpalDeer · 09/04/2025 20:55

Hi everyone,

Me and my partner are first time buyers and have just had a survey done on the property we’re hoping to buy. Results are quite promising considering the age of the property, the only issue we may have found is with the roof/chimneys.

We have found the process relatively straightforward so far, but we’re stuck as to whether to negotiate as we have no idea what is reasonable and what isn’t! So just looking for opinions really on whether it is worth negotiating based on the following:

  • Weathered and recessed mortar beds and areas of vegetation to be growing in the masonry of 3 redundant chimney stacks. The surveyor advised repointing and masonry repairs to be undertaken in the short term. The surveyor also said “you should anticipate areas of the lead flashing, which is in place between the roof covering and the chimney stack, to be redressed in areas.”
  • Several slipped, damaged, or cracked roof tiles need refixing in the short term.
  • There are some sections of cracked and broke away mortar noted on the mortared fillets between our roof and the neighbouring roof, which surveyor recommended to be “detailed and made good”.
  • The are further slipped and damaged roof tiles noted on the lean-to roof covering at the building. Surveyor recommends these should be replaced at the time of works to the main roof covering. In the same area, ridge tiles are bedded into the mortar, to the surveyor says to anticipate these tiles to need repointing and re-bedding.

As I’ve said, we really don’t know whether it is reasonable or not to ask for a negotiation on price (or ask for work to be done before we exchange and complete, if the seller prefer). So honest feedback would be really helpful here :) Thank you!

OP posts:
friendlycat · 09/04/2025 22:54

I actually did this type of work before I sold as it came up on my previous house. The cost of scaffolding adds up as they need it to access to do the work. It was £1750 but 7 years ago London.

None of what you’ve said is a big job, but I would ask them to fix with proof of invoice.

Onthelinetoday · 10/04/2025 03:50

They are small jobs and not worth losing a house you presumably like over. Ask, but be prepared for them to say no. I would tell a buyer asking for this to stop messing around.

MolluscMonday · 10/04/2025 04:00

I’ve bought and sold a dozen or so houses and i’ve never read a survey that didn’t say stuff like this about roofs! It’s just part and parcel of house maintenance to me; I wouldn’t try and get money off for it and I would tell you a firm no if you were my buyer and you tried.

I think house surveys are a giant racket tbh.

Good luck though, it’s an exciting time of life. Hope you love and enjoy your new home when you get there :)

examadmin · 10/04/2025 04:09

How long term is this house? Is it a "forever home" or a stepping stone house?

If its a "forever" home it could be that you end up getting the roof completely redone anyway in the short/medium term meaning these issues would be sorted then but if it's a house you'll only be in for a couple of years before moving on then I'd be inclined to leave it for now and save a couple of grand in reserve for if you NEED to pay for it later. These are really common issues in older properties and the survey always points out stuff like this needs doing to 'make good' but trying to negotiate over something this "little" in the grand scheme of buying a property risks losing it and/or collapsing any chain you're in.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page