Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

More expensive flat or Pension

4 replies

Summer2025 · 26/03/2025 07:04

If you had 1 child (vasectomy so this is guaranteed) and already live in a small 400k+ 2 bed flat near good london state schools, would you upgrade to a 700k to 750k 2 bed flat (no difference in size) in a nicer area (excellent state primary), stay put or move to a 500k 2 bed flat nearby (essentially lateral move but more space)..

I would 100% prioritize private school fees over housing and as we bought our flat young, we would be mortgage free in our 40s (I am 32 and expecting) as long as our mortgage doesn't substantially increase. And if private school fees are unaffordable for us down the line, we would send our child to state school, I just don't want to eliminate the option at this stage. Particularly before secondary age, I would have at least 7 years to save even if child went to state primary esp with a low mortgage (mortgage 1282). Same applies for university.

Dh wants to do both- 750k flat and private school but I doubt we could save a decent pension with that unless our salaries increase. We wouldn't have any inheritance as our parents favour our younger siblings. I suppose we could downsize the flat to live in a cheaper area in retirement (not in terms of size as it would be small) but at the same time, there is an article in the Ft that very few people make money from downsizing so it seems a risky strategy.

As for PP suggesting I leave London, I don't want to and the state school options I have access to are better (as I belong to a religion) and also that ship sailed in 2017.

Flat prices in London have stagnated to the extent that i can't really afford much in the Home Counties to justify the insane commuting cost. And the cheaper areas in London where your money goes further would be a downgrade in schooling options (as I live near one of the top 15 primary schools in the whole of the uk) - plus DH doesn't want to move to those places.

At least in London my dh cycles everywhere so we barely spend anything on transport.

OP posts:
Flipperti · 26/03/2025 07:12

I don't understand why you feel the need for private education when you have "good" and "excellent" state primaries available.

Summer2025 · 26/03/2025 07:21

Flipperti · 26/03/2025 07:12

I don't understand why you feel the need for private education when you have "good" and "excellent" state primaries available.

I think it's because I want it to be an option. I want to try for 4+ and 7+. Dh isn't a total fan of the state primary nearby (which apparently is top 1% in terms of results) but we shall see. Also prep schools prepare you for 11+ though I know that in that state school, 30% do go to private school. Or if my child gets to an all through school that would also be great. One option could be sending to state primary and then doing 7+ (as 11+ more stressful) but if I stretched myself on property, I might still be able to afford it esp if incomes increase but something will always go .

I think we would stay put for 4 years as I am unlikely to be able to find anything in the same catchment though the catchment is growing.

OP posts:
Summer2025 · 26/03/2025 07:30

Flipperti · 26/03/2025 07:12

I don't understand why you feel the need for private education when you have "good" and "excellent" state primaries available.

Also cos I believe primary residential property isn't an asset. DH's mum has a 700k house and is no better for it, she would never downsize despite having no pension. Ironically the people I know who downsize are the people who don't need the money and generally go for luxury flats cos they want to live in their homes longer.

My flat is definitely a depreciating possession despite having no issues, low service charge, residents own the freehold. I am very glad I bought it though cos we spent 5 years paying 1k mortgage when our earnings were pretty low (first 3 years). And now during maternity leave my mortgage is still 500 quid cheaper than if I rented the same flat with more security. Dh thinks the more valuable flat would be easier to rent out which would give us flexibility and we could rent in other places (giving us more options for schooling). He has never rented in the uk before (while I rented as a student), only overseas when doing his masters as he just went straight from the family home (we stayed there while I was waiting for my visa/launching careers) to buying. I don't have such a rosy tinted view of renting.

So I guess if I want to stay in London, I want to live in the cheapest property near good state schools in a nice area (which would be a flat ) and only have 1 child, this does make private education an option.

OP posts:
ThatHazelGuide · 26/03/2025 07:47

This is hard, because as you say London house prices are not rising consistently and insanely like they have in the past. It's not an easy decision with any guarantees either way.

I'd go for the best property I can afford near a good school in a good area.

But I'm not you. I'm afraid this is ultimately your roll of the dice. Hopefully you'll buy wisely, the markets will be in your favour and the area will prosper.

Good luck op 🤞

New posts on this thread. Refresh page