Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Nice house in wrong location or project in good location?

32 replies

Nomorediy · 13/12/2024 22:26

I live in St Albans and I have sold my house without seeing anything obvious to buy.

This area is fantastic if you have a £1m budget but mine is more like max £620k (single mum) and with kid settled in secondary I don’t want to disrupt them by relocating to eg Hemel or Welwyn where we don’t know anyone. I ended up here because it made much more sense when married on 2 salaries. I’d rather compromise as much as possible here than leave. My exh is close by (50-50) and I have a great group of family friends here I’ve known since kid started nursery. Also for medical reasons I can’t drive.

I sold a small terrace out of sheer desperation for more living space. And I can obtain this locally, but I am choosing between compromises. Which might be the easiest compromise?

3 bed in quite far-flung suburbs (Drakes Drive/New Greens for those who know the area), cabs to station for work and to see friends. Bit isolated maybe but family areas so we’d get to know neighbours I hope. I love to entertain and I’m sure friends would drive/cab to me.

3-bed flat in the centre, so no garden for summer bbqs but these are not exactly frequent events. Usually best way to obtain space cheaply. I do have a cat tho. Not keen on litter trays. Bit worried about leasehold and service charges and noise.

House nearer the station (Hatfield Road/Fleetville/Camp area for those familiar). Those in my budget generally need a lot of renovation I don’t really have money for. So compromise here would be saving up for 5 years for new kitchen, bathroom etc. or maxing the mortgage, in either case cutting lifestyle spend back to the bare minimum (no holidays, meals out, planned weekly shops in Aldi, very little socialising outside the home, clothes from charity shops/ebay only/packed lunches).

I know this is all a first world problem. Living in a suburb or a flat or living frugally is what many many people do. It’s compromise rather than deprivation. I’m just not sure what compromise to choose.

What would you do?

OP posts:
martinisforeveryone · 15/12/2024 18:40

If you'd be perfectly happy to live in that house as it's arranged then I'd save your money and leave it all alone, after all, the current vendors have also been happy and they, or their predecessors went with the plans as is.

I doubt you'd achieve a higher rental especially considering the outlay on reconfiguring and if it's in a good primary catchment, then the likelihood is that potential tenants would like one or more bedrooms for children/baby. If not, then the box room could be a WFH space.

Go and have a look and see how it suits you because it sounds as though it does have enough attributes to appeal to the rental market.

RoamingGnome · 15/12/2024 21:56

I'd look at the cost of a loft conversion (depending on how long you're going to be living there for). Use the smallest bedroom as upstairs shower room & loo, add a master with en suite in the loft and either keep the downstairs bathroom (any family with young kids will want a bath) or partly/fully convert to big utility/laundry room. Will all cost a fortune though!

Nomorediy · 16/12/2024 18:52

RoamingGnome · 15/12/2024 21:56

I'd look at the cost of a loft conversion (depending on how long you're going to be living there for). Use the smallest bedroom as upstairs shower room & loo, add a master with en suite in the loft and either keep the downstairs bathroom (any family with young kids will want a bath) or partly/fully convert to big utility/laundry room. Will all cost a fortune though!

Yes this was my thinking. Move in now and borrow for a loft conversion when mortgage rates fall (hopefully) or don’t fall and builders have to back away from 2021 prices!

OP posts:
TheFormidableMrsC · 16/12/2024 19:00

I know St Albans well, I have family over Cathedral side. I also had friends where you are looking, nearer the station. I'd go for that in your situation. I wouldn't want a flat in the centre, especially in the summer when it's busy and noisy. You'd still be able to get around quite quickly. Just wondering why water would be dripping through the house? Surely you dry off properly before exiting the bathroom?

Sparsely · 16/12/2024 19:36

What about this one? Offer £590k. Spend £10k on paint job for rest of house, new carpets, DIY reno job for kitchen (redo wall tiles, new knobs, paint cabinets), Then £20k upgrading end of garden office with a shower. You can Air BnB it or rent it out (£7k a year tax free) and pay for rest of house upgrade you want with that.

It's perfect if you can't drive. 5 mins walk to Morrisons. post office, cafes, restaurants within walking distance. Traffic free walk down Alban Way to startion in the sunshine. Bus upon bus outside your door in the rain.

The big downside is it is very close to a busy road. But U think the income stream would help you.
https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/155108987#/?channel=RES_BUY

Nomorediy · 17/12/2024 18:24

Sparsely · 16/12/2024 19:36

What about this one? Offer £590k. Spend £10k on paint job for rest of house, new carpets, DIY reno job for kitchen (redo wall tiles, new knobs, paint cabinets), Then £20k upgrading end of garden office with a shower. You can Air BnB it or rent it out (£7k a year tax free) and pay for rest of house upgrade you want with that.

It's perfect if you can't drive. 5 mins walk to Morrisons. post office, cafes, restaurants within walking distance. Traffic free walk down Alban Way to startion in the sunshine. Bus upon bus outside your door in the rain.

The big downside is it is very close to a busy road. But U think the income stream would help you.
https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/155108987#/?channel=RES_BUY

Edited

I have my eye on that one! Small world eh?!

It is bang next door to a busy pub and the road is very very noisy. I’m not sure a mortgage lender would be secure about the pub next door? It was on the market a couple of years ago and then pulled.

Your garden room idea is fab! Could rent it out as a workspace too.

OP posts:
Nomorediy · 17/12/2024 18:26

TheFormidableMrsC · 16/12/2024 19:00

I know St Albans well, I have family over Cathedral side. I also had friends where you are looking, nearer the station. I'd go for that in your situation. I wouldn't want a flat in the centre, especially in the summer when it's busy and noisy. You'd still be able to get around quite quickly. Just wondering why water would be dripping through the house? Surely you dry off properly before exiting the bathroom?

My delightfully clumsy teen would drip water through house and/or wander into garden instead of bathroom thorough those French doors lol.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page