Which of these hallway lights for Victorian house?

[AmoebaOnFlea]

It’s a terraced house with quite a large/high ceiling hallway and porch. not sure which of these would look better - or something else entirely? Thanks

I vote second one

First one

First one.

First. 2nd looks good for outside.

First

Second one ☝️

2nd one

Second one

First one

The first one is gorgeous.

Both lovely. Depends on the size of each light and your hallway, of course.

2nd one

2nd

First one is a more unusual shape but I really like them both.

Both are lovely but I prefer the first

( unless they are small and would be dwarfed)

Have they got any pics of the first one switched on? Cos those three round bulbs all pointing down may look really odd when turned on.

I like the round one.

The second one would be more authentic but the first one would cast more light because of the bulbs pointing down. In a hallway that's important.
They're both fine though. Have you physically seen them and seen them lit? If you've only seen them online you may not get the full picture.

Second will be a nightmare to dust.

First one

First one

I like the first one, it has a slightly steam punk look to it which is a play on victoriana anyway.

Interestingly, when I see the "Similar threads" at the bottom of your thread there is a similar thread which I've linked. There is a photo of the first lamp, or one very similar to it, in situ in a Victorian hallway.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/property/4846606-ceiling-lights-for-victorian-property

Ooh thanks everyone! 💐

The round one is so pretty!