Aah it was me who made the comment about being a scientific way.
Just to expand on that a little, as it maybe sounds insulting and it wasn't meant to be.
When I was researching mist coats no one could seem to agree on the correct ratio for diluting the paint. Experts were contradicting each other and there were forums full of professional painters/decorators arguing about how much to dilute it. Even on here there are threads with different recommendations from experienced posters.
I looked up the paint that you recommended and the manufacturer says to dilute it with "up to" one part water to five parts paint. I find these kinds of instructions impossible to follow!! What does "up to" actually mean? What happens if I put less water in and not the full 1/5 ratio - because saying "up to" implies you might sometimes need less than the full 1/5 ratio??
For full transparency, I am autistic and I really struggle with instructions that aren't clear. So when there are instructions that imply 1/5 might not be the exact correct ratio, and when there are experts disagreeing with each other, it just all becomes confusing and I end up paralysed by indecision!
If I water the paint down, I'll just be taking a punt that I've done the right ratio of paint to water - so that's what I meant about preferring to use breathable paint that's designed for the purpose. Not having to guess feels more "scientific" to me - but I do appreciate that's because I struggle with ambiguity probably more than most! Being able to buy a paint that I can just use out of the tin means I don't spend ages agonising over how to dilute it 😅
Also, I've never had to deal with new plaster before and now I've got an absolute ton of it. Once I've done something once and know what I'm doing, I'm fine. If my lovely, now-departed dad was still around he would have known the right way to dilute it and would have told me exactly what to do. You're obviously a bit of a pro at this (genuine compliment, not sarcasm!) so I just wanted to say I wasn't implying that your way is shit, it's just too confusing for my brain!