I wanted to canvass views on what is reasonable to expect in this circumstance. There is a good relationship between landlord and tenants.
A tenant is in a rented property shared with a friend as co-tenant. Tenant 1, who is in the Master bedroom with an ensuite bathroom, reports to the rental agency that manages the property on behalf of the landlord, that the hinge on the bathroom mirrored cabinet had become loose and one of the doors had fallen and smashed.
On a good faith understanding that this was just an accident, perhaps caused by a screw that had become loose over the year during the term of the tenancy so far, who should pay to replace the cabinet? Landlord or tenant?