Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Young building company vs established expensive one?

4 replies

BlogOnTheTyne · 27/07/2013 14:03

Been on here a few times recently about our possible garage conversions - one either side of the house and each attached to the house.

A local established and recommended building company quoted me around £50,000, including VAT to convert them!! Now I've got another much 'younger' company - young directors, recently established (one's a carpenter and one's a brickie by trade) not yet VAT reg. who've quoted me £26,500 (no VAT).

Is that a reasonable quote for converting two garages - one to include a shower room/toilet? It seems higher than I'd expected, given they're recently established. I was thinking along the lines of about £15k in total - but is that unrealistic for two garages?

On another thread, someone said they'd only paid £1K to £2K for a single garage conversion. So I'm deeply confused, given one company quoted £50K (they'd originally suggested £60K) and this tiny new company now suggests £26,500.

Is this much lower - but still not that cheap - quote indicative of a possible botched job to come - or would it be a good, reasonable figure for potentially serious, professional works?

Both companies have been recommended by acquaintances who've each used one of them for their own other building works. I really liked the two young directors of the new company, as there wasn't an 'edge' to them - but I may be a hopeless judge of character (and they were very good-looking!).

The other company sent the owner out - much much posher middle- aged man who was a bit condescending - and took nearly 4 weeks to get back to me and return my plans, having said he'd get back to me within a few days.

Should I get a third quote before deciding what to do? There's no question of going with the expensive company, as I can't afford it but the smaller company is still more than I'd hoped to spend too.

OP posts:
Pascha · 27/07/2013 14:13

To clarify:

The established company was condescending, took ages to get back to you and are expensive? They don't want your business, they are pricing high and taking ages to make you go somewhere else so thats what you should do.

I would definitely get a third quote and make sure the quote is like-for-like in terms of materials, labour and so on, then pick the company who you have most affinity with, having checked out the work of both.

BlogOnTheTyne · 27/07/2013 14:42

Thanks Pascha.

Is £26,500 a reasonable quote for converting two attached garages, one with a shower and toilet/sink addition?

OP posts:
Pascha · 27/07/2013 15:18

Dunno, depends on how much work is involved really. To out it in context we did a kitchen/utility/shower room extension for approx £40k including fitting and finishing, the actual building work was about £28k. I would have thought £26k would get you the conversi

Pascha · 27/07/2013 15:22

Crap. Try again:
I would have thought £26k Would get you the conversion but not necessarily the finish, iyswim. Only way to see if it's a good price is to compare it to another one.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page