I agree with you — the whole RGS move to co-ed feels less like a bold educational vision and more like a practical reaction to the fact they haven’t been getting enough of their ideal boy for a while now. Their intake has always been quite narrow, and there simply aren’t enough of those “perfectly still, high-performing from age five” boys in the area to sustain that model. Their results have also been edging down over recent years, so suddenly opening to girls doesn’t feel entirely coincidental.
One thing people often forget is that Guildford already has Rydes Hill. It’s been co-ed in the younger years for ages and is moving fully co-ed up to Year 6. We considered it for our DD many moons ago, and it was our backup to Tormead at the time. Families we know rate it highly — especially for boys who might not thrive in a high-pressure or selective environment. It’s relatively small, but I guess nurturing and not an exam-factory. It’s also historically succeeded in getting boys into RGS when that’s been the right choice, alongside girls into the usual Guildford Seniors - GHS, TOrmead, StCats, etc..
On the Tormead side, the Prep is genuinely lovely. We had daughters there before they grew! — everything is built around it being 100% girls, and the culture, teaching style and opportunities all reflect that. That’s something I genuinely worry about with RGS: after being boys-only since the 1500s, the idea that they’ll suddenly master girls’ development, learning styles and pastoral needs in about 12 months feels… optimistic. It’s a huge cultural shift, not something you can just bolt on with a new brochure or an AI generated advert of some girls in their uniform. Tormead, St Cats and GHS have been educating women for hundreds of years and are clearly very good at it.
If you’re worried about splitting your two, don't quote me, but there appears to be a daily shuttle between Rydes Hill and Tormead for families with boys at RH and girls at Tormead, the bus passes our house every day. Might help with logistics - maybe ask?
That said, if your current co-ed prep is working for your DS, there’s no reason to uproot him, but I wouldn't pass off Tormead if you're next door for your DD.
Guildford is tricky for boys, absolutely — but you do all these options, even if RGS isn’t quite the straightforward co-ed solution they’re trying to present. We'll have to wait and see!