Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Primary education

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

Calling Governors

8 replies

terryandgerry · 06/07/2010 21:06

I have had a somewhat fractious relationship with my son's school for the past year. There are lots of very good things about it, but the situation has become difficult because if their failure to respond and monitor his SEN. There has been very poor record-keeping, unwillingness to access expert advice and work with us as parents. He is autistic (diagnosed this year) and very able but underperforming because of his difficulties.

Anyway, two vacancies arose for Governors? positions and I thought this would be a good opportunity to feed into school policy in a constructive way. I have always been very involved in school activities (PTA, helping out on trips etc) and I would rather work with than against.

I knew the Head would not be happy to see me as a Governor. He is very dictatorial and precious about his ?outstanding? school but very defensive and hard to work with. He finds it difficult to see other views. Parents always feel communication with the Head is poor. He calls them apathetic. I thought I could work to improve this.

Anyway, a failure of more than two applicants saw me and one other appointed without election as Governor.

News of our appointments went out to parents.

Two days later, I was approached by the Head who said (perhaps I imagined the glee!) that my appointment had been rescinded because certain issues had been raised about the appointment. A standard nomination form had been issued which gave a date from last year. At an open evening for new parents (for next year?s intake) a couple of existing parents had spoken to the Governors present about this and said they had missed their chance to apply. She said they would have to hold the nomination process again.

I received no apology from the Governors until I wrote to the clerk and pointed out that they should be open about their mistake and I asked whether the decision to rescind appointments was made by the Governing Body.

I begrudging apology was then made and I was told there rules about returns of forms were clear (i.e. to be returned within 14 days) so it wasn?t their fault parents had been confused. Governors would be deciding how to proceed with a new nomination/ballot but as it was nearly end of term this may now be next year.

I asked that parents be told what had happened and that, if others were interested, that this be welcomed as a sign of increased engagement. I emailed this to the Head too.

I?ve heard nothing since and no correction has gone out. I imagine they?ll gloss over it all and just send out letters next term saying ?we have two vacancies?.

Am I being petty or do you think this is a poor show? I wondered who had the right to overturn the appointment anyway? I wouldn?t want to cling to an appointment if it had been unfair but this all seems very high handed.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
terryandgerry · 06/07/2010 21:08

Cor, sorry about typos!

OP posts:
Carryoncatsbum · 06/07/2010 21:32

I am a Governor and find this pretty shabby. Contact your local LA who should have a governor helpline for advice on this. Sounds like he is trying to put barriers in your way.

IndigoBell · 06/07/2010 21:41

I had an experience a bit like this. I have seen all sorts of shoddy things done by headteachers.

After my experience of being a governer (my DS too has ASD) I ended up moving school.

Thing is you can fight this (talk to your LEA school governers rep), or you can re-apply next year, or you can accept the HT doesn't want you to be a governer - and probably doesn't want your son there either.

Sorry to be so negative. But all I can say is we are so glad we have now moved to a school that is good with SEN

terryandgerry · 06/07/2010 21:47

Thanks for this.

Wouldn't a decision have to be made by all the Governors to rescind my appointment once made?

I presume Governing bodies are covered by some sort of constitution. Do they call it a constitution? I was going to ask for a copy to see if it has been followed.

As far as I know, no written complaint was made, it was just chat at a parents' evening.

OP posts:
HappyMummyOfOne · 06/07/2010 21:51

I doubt the decision was made by all Governors but if a parent had questionned the procedure and there were errors made then I think the people newly appointed would have the position rescinded and new notifications re the vacancies should go out. The chair would make the decision if procedure had been done incorrectly.

I'm new to the role though so only guessing.

terryandgerry · 06/07/2010 21:55

Thanks. I suppose I just feel that could have been handled better, e.g. a proper apology and then letting people know what had gone wrong.

OP posts:
admission · 06/07/2010 22:17

The election of parent governors is actually a function of the LA for community schools, though it is usually delegated to the headteacher. If the school is a foundation or faith school then the responsibility for the elections rests with the governing body, though it can be delegated to the LA or the headteacher.

If there were obvious procedural errors then I think it is only fair that the process is re-run but I suspect that you might just find that there is at least one other candidate next time, so creating an election. I would suggest that you keep an eye open for the notice of the need for nominations as I would not really too much on getting a favours about knowing about the new elections.

terryandgerry · 06/07/2010 22:26

Thanks. Yes, it is a community school and the head sent out the letter about nominations.

I would expect he would have to put out a formal notice asking for fresh nominations.

Annoyingly, one of those who moaned about it said her husband had wanted to stand. I don't think she expected them to overturn the appointments and now says sheepishly, her husband hasn't really got the time.

I know someone else is interested though and with the new intake next year, you've always got a chance to get more nominations.

It is inarguably right that if there is any suggestion that the nomination process went wrong, it should be put right but I still can't help feeling this worked out very nicely for the head!

Also, I may be being silly, but I really think a bit of humble pie (apology and explanation to parents) wouldn't go amiss.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page