Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Primary education

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

Parent's night tonight. I want to bring something up that annoyed me, not sure if I am being totally PFBy. Come and tell me what you think.

37 replies

ElizabethWakefield · 30/03/2010 13:12

DD is 9 in P5 (in Scotland so that is a class of 9 and 10 yr olds) They have a newly qualified teacher this year, she seems fine, but she can be quite sarcastic with the children which they don't always get, apart from that, I have no issues with her or anything.

So, all year DD has had pretty much the same homework every single night, putting 5 words in a sentence, she hates doing it, gets bored and moans every single night.

At the end of Feb they are told that instead of their usual homework, they are being given a month to do their own individual project, which is to be done in the evenings instead of usual homework. It was to be started on 1st March and handed in on 29th, so giving them 4 weeks to do it. Each child in the class was given a country to research and a list of things to include, like festivals, famous people, capital city etc.

DD got really into it and loved doing it, spent time on the internet, went to the library, learned some words, cut out pictures from a travel brochures, spent ages doing it.

3 weeks in, they had to take it in for the teacher to do a progress check. So by this point DD had done 20 pages, the other kids had done 5 or 6. Teacher praised some other children's work and said to DD "You have done a bit much, start to finish off now" DD said she still had a couple of things she wanted to add in, the teacher said she would rather she didn't, but was up to her. DD came out of school saying her project must be rubbish as the teacher gave a positive comment to everyone else (her friend confirmed this) so from that night DD didn't do anything else and totally lost enthusiasm.

They had to take their projects in again on friday, for another inspection, before handing it on on Monday (yesterday) for a final check. DD had done nothing at all since the last check. Again, the teacher commented to some children that she was looking forward to reading theirs etc, to dd she commented, she didn't know where she would find the time to read it. (but not in a nice way)

So over the weekend DD only added a summary page at the end at that was it. Handed it in yesterday and got a "Here comes DD and her novel"

Now I don't know if I am being PFB or whatever, but I feel the teacher was a bit nasty, DD was so into the project and was really enjoying doing it and was quite proud of it, and the teacher just totally put her off. Surely it is not the job of a teacher to knock the work of a child.

Now, if she couldn't be arsed reading them, why not say, to do 10 pages or whatever on a certain country, rather than giving a month.

So, it's still annoying me, as it only happened yesterday, I want to bring it up tonight (to be honest if it wasn't parents night I wouldn't really make an issue out of it) just not sure how to word it withou sounding like I am wanting her to praise DD, which I don't, I just don't want her to be put off learning.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
ElizabethWakefield · 30/03/2010 21:13

Quick update for all the nosey folk

I actually think DD's teacher might be insane, but that's besides the point. She spoke a bit about DD's work and showed us some examples etc, including a a spelling mistake where DD had written sissors and she had crossed it out and put sciccors as a correction!

Anyways, she mentioned the project and said it was good, so I asked if she thought so, and explained what I said on this thread, she acted surprised and then said it sounded like DD put in a lot of work, so I said that she had and explained what she had done etc, and she said that she wasn't aware of that as she hadn't even looked at it, so I said that she might want to try looking at things in future before she put them down

So then she said to me "I've heard you correct spellings at home" and I said that yes, if I see a spelling mistake in DD's homework I will point it out and help her correct it and she said "yes, I've heard that about you"

Is doing that not fairly normal??

Anyway, I then questioned if there will be more project work, or some more challenging/interesting homework, and hurrah hurrah, she said that the teacher she used to job share with (old teacher did 3 days she did 2) is back after Easter and will be taking DD's class full time until summer. I'm actually really pleased as DD had the other teacher in P4 but she was off having a hysterectomy.

So alls well that ends well!

OP posts:
megapixels · 30/03/2010 22:06

Thank goodness for that ElizabethWakefield (is that the character in Sweet Valley High?), she really does sound barking. at 'sciccors' and "I've heard that about you".

busymummy3 · 30/03/2010 22:46

This so annoys me especially when your child has written a great story or project and really has put a lot of effort in using exciting vocab and WOW words(latest phrase my kids are using for school homework "we must use plenty of WOW words"
It comes home 2 weeks later with a solitary red tick no comments no words of wisdom or praise why do they do this if they cant be bothered to write something at the end good or bad to at least acknowledge that they have read it?

Spacehopper5 · 31/03/2010 00:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

overmydeadbody · 31/03/2010 00:07

YANBU or PFB

The teacher sounds a bit controlling tbh. Yes it is normal for a parent to correct their child's spelling at that age!

Glad your DD will be having the other teacher next term.

MathsMadMummy · 31/03/2010 09:59

busymummy3 - totally agree, it must be very demotivating. my DSDs had WOW words too

OP, I'm guessing teacher doesn't want you to correct spelling at home because then she won't see where your DD struggles? It's a valid point (though I'm sure it's normal to correct to some extent), but she was very rude!

Well done for being so assertive, I probably would've chickened out!

ElizabethWakefield · 31/03/2010 11:33

Have also had the WOW words

I guess that makes sense with the homework, I honestly thought that helping DD to go over it and check for mistakes was the best way to do it. Most times she will notice them herself if she reads through.

I am glad that tomorrow will be the last day with this teacher then the old teacher will start back after the holidays (Old teacher used to be my teacher when I was little )

And, yes, the name is from sweet valley

OP posts:
MathsMadMummy · 31/03/2010 11:57

well that's fine if your DD is mostly the one noticing a mistake, not you pointing it out.

glad she's getting the good teacher!

glasjam · 31/03/2010 13:06

Glad this has been resolved but really hope this teacher has learned a valuable lesson herself and doesn't take this sarcy attitude into another classroom.

I still remember vividly doing a home economics project when I was 11 and cutting out lots of pictures and getting really enthusiastic. It was my first year of secondary school so the first experience of homework. The teacher really put me down for it saying I had gone over the top (but not in a nice way) felt really demoralised. But she was a very unpleasant individual who just took a dislike to me and I couldn't do anything to change her mind. She walked past my desk once when she was pregnant and stumbled into a stool and turned round and shouted at me for nearly causing her to lose her baby It became quite a joke amongst my friends that she really didn't like me. I blame her for my lack of housekeeping skills!

Glad that your daughter will be rid of this teacher's bad attitude and inexperience.

Mrsdoasyouwouldbedoneby · 31/03/2010 13:43

Glad it is sorted now!!

I had teachers take a dislike to me (tbf I probably was annoying...). She told me once that I was unlikely to get anywhere in life and would be a failure etc... Used to give me lines for forgetting to do my homework, and then FIND my book in her bag... she would just say oh dear and pop the lines in the bin.. She would prevent me from stretching myself in her class (academically), and put me on the struggling table... even tho I was more than capable of doing the other work... in fact I learnt it by finishing my easy work very quickly and listening in... I was told off for doing so once! stupidly it still sticks with me, even tho I was only 12 at the time. 20yrs later and it still erks me!

NikkiH · 31/03/2010 19:55

I correct my children's spelling - normally with them by my side so they can see what they've mis-spelt and how it should be written. I also correct my husband's spellings in DS2's reading record and - on occasions - the teacher's too! I can't help it - I'm just anal that way

ravenAK · 31/03/2010 19:59

The teacher has a lot to learn, to put it mildly.

How miserable for your dd.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page