Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Primary education

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

Ability groups in Y1

26 replies

Maxiebaby · 23/10/2009 12:10

Can anyone tell me if ability groups at this tender age are based on ability (ie how bright a child is) or actual attainment. Also, at an age when a year makes a huge amount of difference to their development, to what extent do the groupings tend to reflect birth dates?

DD just had lovely, positive feedback from first Y1 parents' evening. The teacher says she is doing very well academically (April birthday, reading ORT stage 6 with ease for eg), so I was a bit surprised when she told us DD is somewhere in the middle in terms of ability groups. We understand this is because she has a tendancy to rush her work and doesnt therefore do as well as she is able. In which case, are we right in saying that 'ability' groups reflect what a child does rather that what they are actually capable of (which would not, until now at least, have been my definition of ability)?

Can any experienced mumsnetters tell me if the ability groups at this age are a true refelction of ability (in terms of potential) or to some extent of the childrens' relative stages of development and age? If the latter, I guess the groups must be pretty fluid and things will even out??

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
tikkapots · 10/11/2009 11:34

Hi there

This made interesting reading. My LO is in Y1 and always been good with his reading. He was reading the same books as those on the top ability table and 3/4 levels higher than those on his own table.

When I realised this I did ask the teacher why he was in the group he was. Teacher admitted he had outgrown his group and has now changed it so he is still on the same table each morning but moves to the other table for reading sessions. Apparently they move the tables about at the beginning of each term.

I suspect there is only a certain amount of room on each table and grouping the kids can be a challenge. My LO is/was (will find out if he still is at upcoming parents evening) VERY quiet in school and due to this it took a while for his ability to be noticed as he clammed up when with the teacher at base line assessment time.

I am glad he is now reading with other children at the same level and am pleased I asked about it.

He won't be in the top group for maths but thats OK, he needs extra help with maths and will be with those at the same level and will, hopefully, get the extra help he needs.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread