Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Primary education

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

Could your reception age child do this homework ??

88 replies

IllegallyBrunette · 06/06/2008 12:32

Ds has got a sheet with 4 pictures at the top of a Fire engine, firemans boots, firemans uniform and firemans helmet. Each item has a colur next to it to indicate what colour they should be.

The underneath there is a pic of 3 firemen fighting a fire.

Ds has to colour the pic in correctly, using the colours suggested above.

That is fine, he can do that.

Then underneath that there is 6 lines where Ds has to write 2 sentences using the words listed at the bottom of the page.

The words are - engine, hose, ladder, water, put out, fire, danger, wearing, jacket, trousers, suit, helmet, boots.

Now I am assuming that he has to add words such as I, and, The to these words, else a sentence cannot be made.

Last time he had a sheet like this he ended up in tears. His pencil control is still very poor and so his formation of his letters is still very wobbly, and he gets them back to front upside down etc. His writing is also very big in his attempt to control it, and so he can take up a whole line with two words.

If he has a word up in front of him, say on a board, then he can copy it given time, but if he has to keep looking for a word to copy then he loses all sense of what he is doing.
I did write the sentence out for him to copy, and held it up in front of him, but he was too upset by that point.

Last time I let him stop after one sentence as he was so upset. I told his teacher why he'd only done one sentence and although she said it was ok, she looked a bit confused that i'd let him only do the one sentance because of it.

I am surprised that they have given him another similar sheet so soon after that one.

I know he has to learn and practice, but if it upsets him again I am not going to make him do it.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
brimfull · 06/06/2008 17:30

if it upsets him just let him do the bits he can and wants to do

he is only in reception

IllegallyBrunette · 06/06/2008 17:31

It's ok, I did genuinly want to know if others could do it or not.

As I said earlier, my dd's could of done it, so I know that some reception children could.

OP posts:
Madlentileater · 06/06/2008 17:36

NONE of my DCs could have done that in reception and they are all averagely bright or more, and all had excellent nursery experience before school. Just don't bother. I really tink it's out of order giving children this little homework unless it's 'share this book' 'find a picture of..' or maybe colour this in....and then only if they WANT to do it. We have never bothered with HW till Y6, unless it's a project that particulrly caught their imagination.

ChasingSquirrels · 06/06/2008 18:02

I think mine could, I know he could make up a sentance, not sure if he could execute the writting of it.

Enid - re news and doing writing every day, my mum (retired reception teacher) said a few days ago that every year she taught reception her top table would be writing a page and a half by the summer term.

mrz · 06/06/2008 18:19

slayerette what purpose do you think this homework fulfils? IMO it allows the teacher to say everyone in my class gets weekly homework and very little else.
The OP has said her DS has poor pencil control so it isn't appropriate to his writing development.
The task is following a set of instructions which probably require an adult to read. Why set children homework that the parents have to do?

seeker · 06/06/2008 18:27

Insane. Tear it up. Ignore it. Go out to play.
reception children shouldn't have homework at all, let alone demoralizing stuff like this.

singersgirl · 06/06/2008 19:23

I think loads of children in Reception would have difficulty with that task. Lots of children wouldn't be able to read the words independently or be confident writing sentences.It is difficult to make up sentences from a word bank anyway to start off with.

If he really doesn't want to, don't do it. Or you could get him to say what he sees in the picture and then write the initial sounds of the words if he is OK with that.

misdee · 06/06/2008 19:26

dd1 would've needed a lot of my help tp do it, with talkign through and coming up with sentacnes, and then i would 'scribe' for her or she would copy what i had written down on the sheet.

dd2 can manage it fine.

RusselBrussel · 06/06/2008 19:38

Enid, the dc's school does the draw a picture with a sentence underneath too, but only once a month. They call it the 'first day of the month book', and keep it for Reception, Y1 and Y2. Then it is given to the parents to keep. It is lovely to see how drawing/writing comes on over the months

Nutty - tear up the homework. There is now way he is ready for this, and it will not be beneficial to him.
Surely any homework should be taylored to the child's ability?
He is only in reception, too young for this kind of work, tear it up and forget about it.

SpacePuppy · 06/06/2008 19:45

I don't have a child in reception yet, but I would be tempted to let him do what he can, ask him if he wants help, if he says yes, I will assist, if he says no, I will let him get on with it. If he gets upset because its too much of challenge I will leave him and send him to school. The teacher in my opinion cannot be putting pressure on a 5 year old for homework, in fact I think they should all still play outside until they turn 7, finish school at age 18 and be more mature when they go into the wide world (but that is another matter all together)

seeker · 06/06/2008 19:55

Reception children should not have homework.

BabaYaga · 06/06/2008 19:59

I agree with SpacePuppy. Let him do as much as he wants to do, it will put him off writing etc for a long time if he is made to sit and struggle with it. My dd (5) could not do the writing required for this as she like your ds still struggles with pencil control and she hates it when she has to write at school. Hopefully her pencil control will improve the more she draws etc which she does enjoy doing, and then (fingers crossed) the writing will follow. She came home with a proper homework book and 6 spellings to learn this week..this is reception, what happened to PLAY?

hullygully · 06/06/2008 20:03

My ds is extremely bright on g+t blah blah blah, but he couldn't write much before the age of 7 and then not well for a couple of years. Boys just don't have the fine motor skills and it's cruel to make them fail. Tell the teacher she's off her rocker. When my ds used to get upset I used to say that all children had rows of switches in their heads, like for lights, and they all went on at different times so tha this writing one would go on when it was ready. We used to have to write lists of things he was good at to compensate for his feelings of failure. HATE this treatment of kids.

mumto2andnomore · 06/06/2008 21:02

Im a Reception teacher too and wouldnt give homework like that. Goes against the foundation stage philosophy of learning through play and sounds too hard for the level your child is at. My son is in Reception and would struggle with that too.

Enid · 07/06/2008 13:07

Every single child in dd2s reception class wrote a descriptive poem type thing last week. 5 sentences long, all up on the wall for parents to see, obv big discrepancy between letter formation etc but they ALL did it - this isn't 'showing off' but to say that daily practice must work wonders?

chasingsquirrels, dd2s top table regularly write 1.5-2 pages of stories and news in their a5 sized books. Mind you dd2s spelling is pretty, erm, fluid

Enid · 07/06/2008 13:08

tbh I dont think they do learning through play at dd2's school

they've had to put in a 'home corner' this year but use it for doing maths problems only as far as I can see

still they all seem to absolutely love it there and they adore the teacher so who knows?

ChasingSquirrels · 07/06/2008 13:10

its not what they write, but the fact that they are doing it, daily, as you said.

ChasingSquirrels · 07/06/2008 13:10

I don't think ds does much learning through play either - he just does play.

Enid · 07/06/2008 13:14

the reception teacher says she doesnt believe in it

but she is a real old character and often pretends she doesnt know stuff (the date, the day, what 2 +2 is etc) so I think the kids feel that they are being entertained by her while they are actually working IYSWIM

she is brill at sussing them out and encouraging them

she taught dd1 (not bright in reception, very 'behind' other children) and dd1 left her class (she stayed in it for 2 years) thinking she (dd1) was a genius

WonderingWhy · 07/06/2008 13:26

This sounds like something my child would baulk at. He wouldnn't be able to read any of the words unless I did most of the soudning and gave him massive clues.
It seems a bit pointless to have to write a sentence with words he cannot even read.
This is the eternal problem for teachers - trying to accommodate different levels of capability and so on.
I'm sure some of the kids could do it but many could not.

Mine is really going to struggle with year one, they have already told me this

I am seriously thinking of keeping him home where he can do stuff he really is interested in, otherwise I feel there will be many, many tears for him at school.

I'm sorry for your Ds but glad he has a nice supportive mum who isn't too worried about forcing the issue

WonderingWhy · 07/06/2008 13:30

Btw my spelling is actually better than that post would suggest

But my typing is crap today!

Ds's letters are mainly illegible as well. he can write about 3, fairly clearly, the rest just don't resemble - he goes off in odd directions, quite imaginative really

jamila169 · 07/06/2008 13:37

My DS2 wouldn't be able to do it, he's only just got holding a pencil, hes 5 in august, I absolutely refuse to have him do homework in reception,as do a lot of other parents, it's just not appropriate, when their ability and coordination vary so much. My DS gets more out of letter spotting games and drawing pictures anyway. My DD's will probably outstrip him,but girls gain their writing skils much earlier anyway -DD1 could hold a pencil correctly at 18 months and draw tiny circles,neither of the boys could do that

kittywise · 07/06/2008 14:05

My girl at reception age could have done it easily. My older boys at reception age----no way!!!

soapbox · 07/06/2008 14:32

I think the whole point is that it really doesn't matter a whit whether they can or can't do this at this age. It is an indication of how advanced their fine motor skills are - but that is no indication of future academic success.

So whilst Enid;s teacher might have had them slogging away at writing for the last year in a couple of years difference those that have had a year of nothing but play will not be one tiny bit disadvantaged by this (and indeed may well have been advantaged by not having such a dull start to school).

Forgetting dates and numbers etc is par for the course for play-based learning, as is using a home corner for maths play, so perhaps the teacher at Enid's school does more of it than she realises. The DC's reception teacher used to play a mean game of hang man with them at carpet time - curriculum words and spellings learned PDQ whilst having fun, fun and more fun!

mrz · 07/06/2008 16:19

Enid doing maths in the home corner is learning through play as is learning to write in the home corner by writing shopping lists or recipes or notes on the telephone as is learning to read in the home corner by reading labels on product or magazines or telephone directories. My class write every day and they read every day but I wouldn't ever give a reception child the type of work described in the OP.