Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Primary education

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

DD1 (8) and the terrible library books she is expected to read - I need a PLAN to discuss with teachers at parents evening next week, long and possibly v boring, sorry.

61 replies

TheHonEnid · 26/02/2008 10:03

I know I witter on endlessly about dd1's reading but still, sorry, here I go again. Its parent's evening next week and dh and I agree we need to go in there with a plan.

Basically dd1 is NOT a strong reader. She did make it through treetops (ort) 11 and 12 but with some difficulty. After level 12 they can choose their own books from the library which are sorted 'appropriately'. Dd1's books have an orange sticker. There is one very short shelf of these - I cannot impress upon you enough the utter crapness of the books - 'Stories for 4 year olds' (mmm not many year 3's wanting to take that one), 'The Gargoyle' ok quite good story but MUCH too hard for dd1 'Little People Big People' by Malachy Doyle with lots of Irish names and slang which just utterly confuses a weak reader (and its a crap book anyway). There are a couple of Usborne (yay!) and a few Ginn 360 (v good for dd1, simple nature stories). dd1 is expected to choose her own, except she doesn't, I go in there with her and choose them for her.

The terrible books mean that our daily reading has become a terrible battle - she hates doing it and I get irritable . She guesses words, ignores fulls tops and commmas, has NO CLUE what she has just read etc etc.

There are so many good books out there for readers like her -the book people do some fantastic sets - she read and enjoyed the Sprinters series and reads the Usborne abridged classics very nicely and with interest.

I am thinking that I might suggest supplying dd1 with her own books and asking if that would be acceptable. The odd thing is that they have boxes of books in the classroom that are much better in content and style - they can borrow these but they don't 'count' towards their reading record.

Tbh, she should still be on some sort of reading scheme, but this would be very hard to implement now as she thinks she is a 'free reader'.

Need a plan that will help dd1 without utterly alienating her teacher.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
barbarianoftheuniverse · 28/02/2008 10:45

Hi HonEnid,
I said I would get you a list of BarringtonStoke books for your dd.
Here is the list one of the senior editors recommends:
Fox Friend by Michael Morpurgo
The Smallest Horse in the World by Jeremy Strong
PomPom by Michaela Morgan
Tracking by Gill Harvey (FYI title)
Sammy and the Starman by Anne Cassidy
Outcast by Narinder Dhami
The Stepsisters' Story by Kaye Umasnky
Catch A Gran by Diana Hendry
Dragon! By Hilary McKay
Pet School by Jenny Oldfield
Mad Iris and Mad Iris Goes Missing by Jeremy Strong
Zack Black and the Magic Dads by Annie Dalton

Hope it's useful. I have found them to be very good, not just the stories but the easy sentence structure, type face etc.

barbarianoftheuniverse · 28/02/2008 11:09

I meant to also say that if you order and the books arrive looking old it is because they are printed on creamy coloured paper which is supposed to be much easier to read from than white!

TheHonEnid · 29/02/2008 10:20

Thank you so very much barbarian.

Parents eve on Monday will let you know how it goes

She brought home Sheltie In Peril yesterday (perfect for her - horse in trouble) - she borrowed it from the classroom box - she is allowed to read it but not to use it as her 'reading record' - she read it really nicely, simple language and she really cares about the outcome so is encouraged to read it.

seems insane will challenge strongly

OP posts:
tortoiseSHELL · 29/02/2008 10:26

Enid, glad she's got a book she's enjoying, but your school sounds lunatic! Hope parents' eve goes well on Monday - we've got ours Tuesday!

Sherbert37 · 29/02/2008 10:31

Good luck. Saw DS2's lovely teacher this week. She lets him read his magazines in library time as he can't cope with fiction (severe dyslexia). 'I'd rather he read those than sat staring at a book he doesn't want to read'. My thoughts exactly.

TheHonEnid · 04/03/2008 17:16

Ok parents evening went quite well

it turns out that dd1 has been receiving extra help with her literacy since the beginning of term (er thanks for letting me know)

one of the teachers (there are two form teachers both part time) admitted straight away that the library was crap - the other one wouldnt have it. Dh was rather good and just laughed it off and said well we are just going to supply dd1 with her own books 'my wife is excellent at choosing them' ( thanks mumsnet).

Have asked PTA for more books for library but dont think they took seriously, will ask govs.

I recieved the Magic Tree House books from amazon - dd2 fell on them with total excitement , which meant that dd1 then didnt want them

OP posts:
mrz · 04/03/2008 21:00

As a teacher I would be overjoyed if parents extended children's reading by buying or visiting the library.

roisin · 04/03/2008 21:12

That sounds positive Enid.

Are teachers now happy for you to write in reading record any books she reads, whether from the right school shelves, or from classroom box, or home, or the library?

Califrau · 04/03/2008 21:19

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TheHonEnid · 06/03/2008 13:54

BARBARIAN

thank you for that barrington stoke list

I ordered Swop - and my lord if I didn't discover dd1 READING IT UNPROMPTED in her bed this morning, so excited taht she had to read me a bit - THIS IS THE FIRST TIME THIS HAS EVER HAPPENED.

[faint]

will deffo order more, thank you so much.

OP posts:
QueenMeabhOfConnaught · 06/03/2008 14:01

That's great news, Enid - it's fabulous when they find books that they love.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page