Just come across this thread. We are in the same situation as OP with the only difference that our child would start school in 2024. Even so, we al already looking around.
Many of you say that St Norbert is very Catholic. I am Catholic, my DH is CofE, we are not very religious but can put up with that part if otherwise the school has good results academically, especially when it comes to the 11+ results.
Spalding Primary Academy would be our 3rd option, but we can't choose between St Norbert and St John.
St Norbert is somewhat closer to our home, and the last Ofsted rating was Outstanding. However, previous exam results were not so good, and since the Ofsted report the head-teacher has left. In St Norbert there are many Eastern European children, mainly Polish and Lithuanian, we don't mind this, as these kids often work harder than many English students.
St John has a recurring Good Ofsted rating. It is the opposite of St Norbert in the sense that it has the highest percentage of English children among the free primary schools in Spalding. Exam results are in line with the national average but nothing exceptional. I wonder if they are any easier on religion than St Norbert?
St Norbert has had good exam results lately, but there seems to be a high fluctuation in different years. St John seems to be a steady option, nothing exceptional but a reliable and relatively good workhorse.
So that's our dilemma: St John or St Norbert should be or first preference?