Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Primary education

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

Would you/ do you bribe your 5 year old to do 'homework'?

32 replies

eastwest · 25/06/2017 20:30

Put homework in quote marks because it's not necessarily set by the school. Just wondering what everyone's expectations are of their children at this age, and to what extent you feel it is appropriate/ a good idea to bribe them to do homework. I have a 5 year old boy, one of the youngest in his year group. He is very active and hates sitting down to do anything like reading, writing, crafting (though he likes to look at picture books and to be read to). However, his grandmother frequently bribes him to write or read, with a small toy as reward. Will write sentences for matchbox cars, basically. He is on track in terms of what the reception teachers expect from him, and has no special needs. He just doesn't want to write or read. But will do it, if promised a small toy. Stickers are not persuasive.
I'm just wondering if I should be doing what his gran is doing. Do other children just love writing (eg birthday cards, thank-you letters) and do it happily, or do they also have to be bribed in some way to do it, and if so do you think this is normal/okay/ or immoral/ counterproductive...? I don't really have a strong opinion so just interested ot know what others think.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
user789653241 · 26/06/2017 18:40

Writing is hard work and tiring. Have you considered doing not actual writing, but something to build up his fine/gross motor skills?
If they are not developed enough yet, he may find writing hard work. And you can do lots of fun things to develop them in everyday life.
If you are interested, search " fine motor/gross motor skills", mrz has great list of them on past thread to help children develop them.

My ds hated/maybe still hates writing. We have been doing summer diary for a while. He's only written when he wanted to, and 4/5 of them are drawing, collage, etc. and 1/5 writing, but it's better than nothing, and drawing , colouring, sticking etc. help with fine motor skills anyway, so win win situation just doing them!

drspouse · 26/06/2017 19:12

My DS doesn't hate writing but he's poor at it and slow. He loves doing mazes and dot to dots though.

Marv1nGay3 · 26/06/2017 19:20

Five year olds don't need to be doing homework, apart from reading for a few minutes each day.

ittooshallpass · 26/06/2017 21:33

I don't think children should do homework at primary school at all. There is zero evidence that it is of any benefit. As long as your child is enjoying learning and improving that are doing fine.

As an aside... i didn't think boys developed the muscles needed for fine motor skills until they were 7... isn't that why boys don't/ can't write until later than girls?

MrsMulder · 26/06/2017 22:31

I wouldn't and don't push it op. My ds will happily read school books but doesn't like writing. I do get him to write birthday cards for other people and he is ok with that especially if he is going to a party. Another way I have got him to write was when he wanted me to get something from the shops for him so I told him to write me a list, he seemed to enjoy that.

drspouse · 27/06/2017 09:00

itttoo I think you have that a little confused, many boys can write at 5 and most of them can do bead threading, slot posting and Lego at much younger ages. All fine motor skills. Also eating with cutlery.
And if they hadn't developed muscles their hands would be all floppy...

sirfredfredgeorge · 27/06/2017 11:30

itttoo / drspouse I did not believe, nor can I find any paper suggesting that there is any sex related difference in muscle development until puberty - when of course there's a massive one.

Before then it appears a lot of the differences are more social - where girls are pre-supposed to be weaker on the gross movements and better at the fine movements, which can of course lead it to be self fulfilling as the tasks children are guided towards/encouraged.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread