Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Primary education

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

Very bright but won't write - should we worry? DD is 6

33 replies

pippilongsuffering · 15/03/2015 20:14

DD is 6 and in year 1. She is very bright (taught herself to read at 3 blah blah), has the most phenomenal vocabulary and a fantastic imagination but hates writing and refuses to do it. She is doing no work at school on this basis. She gets the top level homework, but getting her to do it is like pulling teeth. She produces very very little written work in the classroom and spends most of the time staring off into space. Her excuse is that she doesn’t like writing, or that the work is too hard. She says she should just be able to tell the teacher the answer.

I also regularly get told by her friends that “oh DD doesn’t ever do any work at school”. (I might mind this particularly today as she didn’t make the Mother’s Day card the rest of the class made because she ‘needed a nap’). She has just started going to Rainbows which she loves, and interestingly participates in all the activities there and comes home buzzing with excitement.

She has been on the SENCo radar at school since she started in the nursery there and has seen the EP on several occasions. They were first involved because of her failure to socialise. This is now starting to improve and she has several friends and there no longer seems to be concern over this. The concern is now her failure to do any work. The EP has said that she is simply very very bright and very very bored and disengaged with the work presented to her and that by the time she gets to Year 2 or 3 she will naturally become more interested as the teachers will be teaching her more things she doesn’t know. The EP says no one is to worry until then, even if her report says everything is ‘emerging’ rather than ‘exceeding’ and that they can teach her everything she needs to know in year 1 in a week if they have to.

I can sort of accept this, but am increasingly worried about the lack of physical writing practice she is getting and whether I should do anything about this. Also we don’t know whether to take a punt on it and hope it works out or whether we should move her to a different kind of school where she could work more to her own interests. There is a Montessori school near us which is lovely and a possibility, but part of us is reluctant to move her now she is settled socially.

She doesn’t seem to mind going to school. At home she is generally lively and funny, definitely quirky and unbelievably stubborn (beyond a normal level of stubbornness). It is difficult to argue with her as she is usually right, and wise in many ways beyond her years. She does come across as socially immature though, though, as I say, improving. She reads and understands books at about a year 5 or 6 level, but as she won’t write it is very difficult for her teacher to give her appropriate extension work.

Has anyone been in a similar situation and come out the other side? Or going through it now? Or have any useful advice on how to deal with the frustration of seeing your child refuse to jump through the hoops and appear to underperform as a result? (perhaps latter most difficult!)

OP posts:
TheFullGammon · 16/03/2015 19:54

What's wrong with her only writing 2 sentences in Y1? Let her hand in the 2 sentences and get some positive feedback for her efforts. Next time 2 sentences will seem a bit easier and next month she might write 3, or she may suddenly decide she can do it and write a whole story.

standingonlego · 16/03/2015 20:36

Reading with interest, having similar challenge with DS2. However, we had a minor breakthrough as he has loved filling in the gaps & lists in this

www.amazon.co.uk/gp/aw/d/0141339667/ref=mp_s_a_1_11?qid=1426538066&sr=8-11&pi=AC_SX110_SY165&keywords=diary+of+a+wimpy+kid+books

mrz · 16/03/2015 21:18

Two sentences in Y1 would be working below end if reception expectations I'm afraid.

poppy70 · 16/03/2015 21:55

It would be better than to train a child whose brain is faster than their hand some strategies to cope. It is hardly an unusual problem. Sound buttons help. Or just doing the long slog with them. Most get there in the end.

pippilongsuffering · 16/03/2015 22:08

The two sentences she wrote were good, but she started with the intention of writing a lot more and then got stuck, so they were only really introductory. I wanted to help her release what she had planned to say. She loved doing it and was really chuffed with her story. Truthfully my concern is more to do with her refusing to do written work at school. I can usually drag it out of her at home.

OP posts:
MilkRunningOutAgain · 16/03/2015 22:38

My DS didn't write til late in yr 1, he is a perfectionist and stubborn and this might have been the reason, I never really worked out why he started joining in class activities, though I was extremely relieved. There were no underlying issues, his writing rapidly caught up with his peers, he's now yr 7 and there don't seem to be any issues. He rarely joined in class work, and was bored, he also took lots of naps, by yr 1 I think this was a way of getting out of doing class work, though he really did go off to sleep, sometimes for the whole afternoon. The school did very little and said they wouldn't worry til yr 2. He was highly articulate and had great mental maths, just wouldn't write it down. Once he did start joining in he was much happier at school, til he did he was a bit of a loner. He is still a very intense child, possibly a bit obsessive about things.

OneInEight · 17/03/2015 06:58

How are her fine motor skills - does she like colouring in or drawing, can she eat with cutlery etc. If these are also not good see if you can get a referral to an OT to see if there is an issue like hypermobility which makes it difficult for her physically to write.

If she is bright has the teacher sat her on a table with others who write copiously and neatly and who might comment on her poor performance. ds2 was getting a lot of negative criticism from his peers which turned him off writing despite them being and I quote "lovely girls".

Handwriting lessons never worked for ds2 as he found them incredibly boring and just turned him off even more. The most improvement he ever made was when a Year Two teacher got the kids to read out their work as there was an incentive for him to write at least legibly enough so he could read his work.

We also found that the more the issue was highlighted the more reluctant ds2 was to write so help had to be given surreptitiously and an awful lot of praise given for what he did produce rather than constant criticism for what he didn't.

zirca · 17/03/2015 07:26

There is a block somewhere. Most likely to be either fine motor skills or spelling. Spelling can be a real issue with early readers as they know when a word is wrong and it annoys them so much that they cannot get every word right that they give up.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page