Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Primary education

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

Is Year 1 teacher affecting DS confidence? Advice please

4 replies

krisskross · 12/12/2013 14:19

DS is 6 and in year 1.

I would say he has always been pretty confident with adults, but found it harder to socialise with children.

During reception he gradually became more outgoing and now plays with a wide group of children in his class and joins in at parties etc and I wouldn't particularly describe him as shy.

He liked his reception teacher alot and did well in class. Both her and the classroom assistant told us many times that he always had his hand up to answer questions, was very confident in answering questions and class discussions etc, but found it harder with the children. So basically their opinion of him mirrored ours pretty much.

At the end of the year we were really happy with his written report- the comments described the boy we knew and his academic performance (for want of a better phrase, given that it was reception Smile ) was really good, exceeding expectations in about five areas.

Fast forward now to year one. Generally, he seems happy.
His teacher seems pleasant. A bit less smiley and nuturing than last year but pleasant.
He goes in happily (which he didnt always last year) and about 8 times out of ten he comes out happy. However, at his open evening in Nov a few things concerned me.

She commented on his lack of confidence in class in dealing with her- this blew me away as it was so different to last year, when his confidence and willingness to join in was commented on many times.

When we met her, he sat a few metres away on the carpet with DD and looked at books. When teacher gently called over to him to ask him a question he noticeably jumped and looked nervous when she asked him......this really surprised me as her tone was pleasant and he generally seems happy with school (and is v enthusiastic about the learning). DH thought perhaps he'd been day dreaming and thats why he jumped....

Last of all, he had his nativity this week. He had two lines which he did clearly and confidently (we thought). Afterwards she said to me " i was so proud of him, especially given his lack of confidence"....then she went off and i was left Shock

My concern is that she has a really different perception of his confidence to us. I know he is bound to be a bit different at home, but his reception teachers seemed to know the same boy we do whereas she is decsribing a different boy.

Is she intimidating him and making him feel less confident? Or is he changing? Or does she not know him?

DH now agrees that this is an issue and we should have a chat with her. She is approachable so we will do this. But I don't really know what I expect from a meeting. ....except that I don't want my DS to lose out because he is labelled as lacking in confidence. I would also say i dont think I am seeing him with excessively rose tinted specs. I was always aware of his shyness with children.

One more thing....we saw all his school books at open eve and it was all positive, no spellings wrong in weekly test, all positive comments about his work etc. And his homeowork is always marked well. But she said "i'm generally happy with his progress" - when we asked what she would want to improve she didnt say anything. Compared to last year when they said they were very happy and he was doing really well.

Apologies for long rambling post, but all advice would be welcome. I have to run now, but will look again tonight. Thank you.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
simpson · 12/12/2013 14:56

Possibly your DS is finding the jump hard from reception to yr1. I don't mean the academic stuff but a yr1 classroom is more formal in the way it is set out and more is expected from the children (again don't so much mean academically) but being more independent, able to concentrate longer, do their work unaided. Now I am not saying he cannot do these things, just that it can be a bit more scary/daunting.

First thing I would do is maybe get his hearing checked.

Also I really would not worry and it sounds like he is doing well. It also sounds like he has a lovely teacher. Kids are bound to be different at home, my DS (yr4) was just the same. He just needed a bit of time to mature, grow in confidence although he is still on the quiet side.

PastSellByDate · 12/12/2013 15:56

Hi KrissKross:

I know you're worried but my advice is hold tight because I suspect several things are going on:

  1. Year 1 can be more formal than Year R - and often children, especially boys, find it tricky to adjust to the new rules.

  2. Year 1 teachers can often be less touchy/ feely than Year R teachers. They're still supportive/ encouraging, but it's less of a caring, relaxed, friendly environment and more, well more like school.

  3. He may be pining for his Year R teacher (certainly DD2 takes at least all of 1st term to get over her previous teacher - it's partly missing genuinely nice teachers but partly missing how things used to be. So in Y2, being a bit blue because she knew where she was at in Year 1).

  4. Every parent has a teacher they don't particularly like. This could be your year to have that teacher.

Now all of the above is telling you you're worrying over nothing - but let's say you aren't...

  1. his jumping up/ being worried may be genuine. Some teacher can seem nice as pie with adults but can do nothing but shout at children in class - often because the class is not well organised or higher ability pupils are finishing work and then have nothing to do whilst waiting for other pupils to finish (again sign of poor organisation).

My feeling is that although this isn't a great environment to be learning in - it is temporary and generally over the course of 7 years in a primary school there is always one teacher you or your child doesn't like. Encourage your DS to work hard, try to please his teacher (within reason) and help him to focus on positive things at school (after school clubs he likes, good friends, exciting trips, etc...).

krisskross · 13/12/2013 09:23

Thanks to both of you responding, especially as my op was so long!!!

Both of you have made helpful points. I had a,chat with him last night and he seems so happy!! I think your comments about taking tjme to get used to the New environment are v true....will spend more time mulling this over.

Thanks again, he us our eldest so it's all new!!

OP posts:
PastSellByDate · 13/12/2013 09:36

Hi krisskross:

I was talking with my DH about our DDs last night and although Y4 & Y6 - they're both absolutely exhausted. We're all relieved there's just one more week of school and then we'll have a nice long break.

I suspect your DS may also be feeling a bit tired out and in need of a rest. A nice break from school may really help.

One thing I do during long holidays away from school is just make sure that a little bit of reading & maths is ticking away. Not overkill - but for instance whilst you're cooking having your DC play a maths game on a computer/ iphone/ tablet/ etc... Try and use the holiday to jazz up your evening reading routine. Maybe start a new book related to christmas or read an old childhood favourite together.

It's lovely time together, time I really enjoy, but I also find it means going back to the routine of school & work isn't such a shock.

HTH

New posts on this thread. Refresh page