I'm just being nosy here, but what is the problem with Bernard Gilpin and Gillas Lane? They're pretty close together, aren't they, so I'm assuming they have a fairly similar intake. I've just checked their last Ofsteds - I said I was nosy!
Interesting that BG has just had one and has been given a notice to improve, although it sounds like they now how have a team in place to make the necessary improvements. It says though that the EYFS and Year 1 are good, and you would hope that the improvements would be in place by the time your dc moved into Year 2.
My kids' school is one in our area that many parents close by look down on, and when my son started there in 2008 they had recently been given a notice to improve. In fact, there were (and probably still are) plenty of people whose attitude to our school was the same as yours towards BG and GL, hence my nosiness about what the problems with them are. However, our school is a lot better than those parents would probably be prepared to acknowledge. Not perfect obviously
but really good. Ofsted were in the week before half term so I'm very much looking forward to finding out if they think it's as good as we parents do. :)
What I'm saying, in a roundabout way, is don't write off either BG or GL just because people whose kids go to other schools badmouth it, if that's the case. Of course, you may know people whose kids are there who advised you against it, which would be opinions actually worth taking into consideration. :)