Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Primary education

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

Year 5 Homework meltdown - help!

29 replies

Whippet · 03/10/2011 10:37

DS is 9 and in Year 5.

We always knew Year 5 would be a 'step up' from Year 4, as they begin to prepare for 11+ exams, but I think it has been quite a big step for DS.

He has about 30 mins of homework per night. Maths tends to be fine.
But anything where he is required to write a reasonable amount (e.g. book review, or comprehension work etc) is causing him to have a complete meltdown.

So far this term we have had

  • being vague about homework in the hope that we won't make him do it
  • saying that he 'doesn't have to do it all' (although when I check , he does)
  • massive tears and tantrums, where he basically just shouts "I don't know what to do/ I can't do it"

I think what he has to do is reasonable for his age/ ability. It is usually set out quite clearly (on a worksheet, or he has copied it off board into homework diary etc) so I just don't understand why he is being so panicky and emotional about it all Sad?

When he starts to argue/ protest about not being able to do it, Dh or I begin patiently - trying to focus on a bit at a time/ pointing out that he's done it before etc, telling him to just try/ offering to explain it if he doesn't understand etc, but he really does just get SO worked up, and shouts at us, coming up with excuse after excuse - it's all "yes, but..." and "no but," and " but I can't".

It's as if he just won't even begin or try!
It then usually ends up in a big scene where DH/I get increasingly frustrated (and sometimes a bit angry Sad) and Ds just gets more and more random/ angry/ aggressive to us Shock.

We've tried 'leaving him to it' but he just faffs around and doesn't do it. We've tried sitting with him, but it's painstaking, and then he just tries to get us to tell him what to write (he's quite sneaky about this).

We need some new strategies - this isn't working. Can anyone help or make suggestions?

I'm going in to chat to his English teacher this week, but in the past when I've spoken to them they've just said not to worry/ he's doing fine etc Hmm.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Takver · 04/10/2011 11:22

Hope it helps, Bramshott. You may find the first book is a little too basic, but certainly with dd it was good to start with things that she could do reasonably easily, IYKWIM.

Helenagrace · 04/10/2011 14:01

All very familiar to me as the mother of a dyslexic, dyspraxic, dysgraphic year 5 DD.

We've worked on DD's handwriting with school. This has helped enormously.

OP you didn't say what time your DC does his homework but I wonder if a snack might help? Low blood sugar won't help with concentration. I give DD an extra snack for the coach home as we were having meltdowns like you describe. It has helped a lot.

We also have a homework box with pencils, ruler, pens etc inside which stops the faffing around trying to find things problem.

Have school noticed a problem with his writing?

Takver · 04/10/2011 14:20

Like the idea of a homework box. Even apart from the stuff, dd does have a dreadful tendency to lose the homework if she does part one night then part the next.

Helenagrace · 04/10/2011 15:04

Oh yes losing homework was a problem here too!

I have a small plastic chest with drawers in. They each have a drawer and then there are two drawers for pens and other kit.

A friend with 6 children, two if which have SN, has adapted the idea. Each of her children has a colour coded lever arch file, each containing a colour coded pencil case.

A sanity saver here!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page