Very interesting responses to my post. I'm glad that I've managed to stimulate a bit of debate, which is always good for learning. (Though I believe it is better in a civil debate to avoid calling those with whom I disagree 'ignorant'.)
There are over a million words in the English language and the vast majority cannot be sounded out. This is hardly a controversial assertion.
Let's take the "at" sound combination for example - which is one of the first sound combinations taught in English. In phonics the "at" sound is typically taught via sentences such as "The cat sat on the flat mat" and so on. It was only fairly recently that an actual study of English was conducted that revealed that "at" only sounds like the "at" in "cat" 25% of the time. The rest of the time the "at" sound can have many other sounds as seen in the following words: ate, water, watch, beat, and attend. How is a child to know which one to choose?
And that's one of the simpler sounds in English. How about the word "rough"? To explain that the letters r-o-u-g-h are pronounced "ruff" you tell a child that the ?gh? combination sounds like ?f.? But that "rule" only goes so far. For example, when you add a th to the front of it. the word becomes "through". Slip in another "o" and it becomes "thorough". (The "ough" combination can have other sounds as well.)
Here are a few other examples that show the changing sounds of letter combinations in English:
car - care - career
real - realm - reality
hear - heart - hearse
face - facet - facetious
The sounds that letter combinations make in English change in ways that are unpredictable for a child. In fact, in English, irregularity is the rule. And for a beginning reader, reading English can be incredibly confusing. To put it simply, if phonics worked as advertised it would be spelled "foniks."
Phonics education attempts to deal with the irregularities of English by teaching almost 600 rules that children are expected to memorize. The problem is that these rules are both impossible for children to memorize and riddled with exceptions.
I appreciate the passion Ms. Hepplewhite has in promoting reading education, and learning the sounds that letters and letter combinations make is a part of learning how to read English. But learning to read requires more than just knowing the sounds. Before criticizing my post I would recommend at least taking the time to do a bit of research on the ingenious work of Dr. Marion Blank (who received her PhD from Cambridge University). You can read more at:
www.readingkingdom.com
and you can also obtain her book, "The Reading Remedy" from Amazon. It is a very enlightening read.
www.amazon.co.uk/Reading-Remedy-Essential-Skills-Reader/dp/047174204X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1295109888&sr=8-1