Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Primary education

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

my ds treated unfairly by his teacher

25 replies

miewie22 · 17/11/2010 00:21

My 9 years old ds is playing for school football team and today he had a home match against another local team. He was very excited about it since we can all come and watch him play. When we were getting ready for school this morning, I couldn't find his other pair of shin pad so I told him to look for it in his PE bag at school but I will get new one from shop just in case and deliver them to him when I come to watch. I got to his school and I managed to give him shin pads just before the match started. But he was substituted for whole first half and after the half time, he still wasn't playing then he came to me in tears and said 'Mummy, the teacher said I am not playing because I didn't have shin pads at the beginning.' I got so angry and took him home straightaway Angry. I knew they were very strict about not forgetting uniform and shin pads etc, but in my opinion, he DID have them!! My husband and I were very humiliated and feel this punishment is too harsh. My ds is very upset about the whole thing. When my husband went back to school to talk to this teacher, he just kept saying that it is their rule and my ds should've had them at the begining and that we were gone when he was going to put my ds on, which is pathetic excuse. I know one of the boy in his team once forgot his football shoes and his dad had to go and get them from home but he was still allowed to play. Sorry for the long story! It is my first time posting. Do you think I should complain about this teacher to Headteacher? I think I would like a formal explanation and apology. My husband says it will only anger this teacher more nd he wil be even more narsty to my ds. We feel pulling him out of this whole thing although he loves football. My ds is saying he doesn't want to continue either. What do you think?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
blinks · 17/11/2010 00:24

a formal explanation and apology is a tad OTT.

i would let it settle and then see if your son wants to go back.

not worth getting your knickers in a twist about it.

OldLadyKnowsNothing · 17/11/2010 00:36

Agree with blinks, it's a fuss over nothing. Forget it.

HeadlessLegless · 17/11/2010 00:42

I have to say that the teacher wanted to teach your son a lesson. It has been learnt, by you and him.

Forget "your" humiliation please. And let your son continue with football as he loves it.

Bet he does not lose his shin pads again and I bet you and DH enjoy another match very soon where he plays a lot.

It is discipline and hard for us to understand as we love our LO's so much but from a teacher's point of view, they have many more LO's than we do and they have to install responsibility for their own actions somewhere.

Lots of hugs, even if it is not MN way.

booyhoo · 17/11/2010 00:47

sorry but this isn't nursery school. if half the team forgot their gear and were allowed to play whenever it arrived there would be no matches til half time. discipline is important, especially with team sports. this school has a rule and the teacher followed through with it. he was right IMO. i bet your son takes extra care with his kit from now on. the point of discipline is to discourage the unwanted behaviour. your son will remember his disappointment and be extra careful in future.

ilovesooty · 17/11/2010 00:49

Shin pads are a H&S issue, and if they have rules they have to apply them fairly and consistently. I'd suggest your son will move on from this more quickly if you treat it as a lesson learned and look forward to supporting him in his next match.

Marchpane · 17/11/2010 01:05

Are you for real? You want a formal apology for a teacher who did their job?

And you stormed off home in a huff?

I think you have too much time on your hands. Have you considered chanelling it into something more productive? It might help you get a bit of perspective.

miewie22 · 17/11/2010 01:18

Thank you all for replying so quickly. After reading your message, you all got a good point. It was lesson needed to be learnt. Maybe I do have too much time on my hands. I acually do. I think I overreacted. Thanks again for your reply though.

OP posts:
PurpleTaipan · 17/11/2010 01:21

Correct me if im wrong OP , but did you storm off home with DS BEFORE the end of the match ?
Did the teacher say he was going to play your DS but you were already gone ?

blinks · 17/11/2010 01:30

refreshing honesty, miewie22.

miewie22 · 17/11/2010 01:34

I did and the teacher said he was going to play him but we were gone when my husband went to talk to him. but I feel I really overreacted now. You are right. this is not nursery school. He needs to take care of things by himself. I needed someone telling me 'Are you serious?'to wake up. So thanks all for giving me honest opinion.

OP posts:
Marchpane · 17/11/2010 01:38

Well done for taking it on the chin Smile I also have a tendency to overreact to things if I haven't got much going on so it wasn't a jibe but a serious suggestion.

MadamDeathstare · 17/11/2010 01:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PurpleTaipan · 17/11/2010 01:41

[GRIN]
well done on your first post Wink

MadamDeathstare · 17/11/2010 01:41

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PurpleTaipan · 17/11/2010 01:42

Grin not [GRIN]

OldLadyKnowsNothing · 17/11/2010 02:32

Well done, miewie22, and welcome to MN. Grin

Akkad · 17/11/2010 02:42

Let your DS sleep on it (for a week), if he still doesn't want to continue, don't.
Imho it was a big overreaction for both of you - heat of the moment, I would imagine.

Also, would another child have been told they are playing in your DSs place? If that was your DS thinking he was playing football today when he usually wasn't then he would have been bloody gutted, and that would have been unfair treatment.

Your DS isn't the only child there, my DDs PE teacher does a headcount of who has kit and doesn't/isn't playing in the morning, so if they aren't playing then, someone else is substituted - this could well be the case at your DSs school.

Goblinchild · 17/11/2010 07:34

I'd let him drop football altogether, it sounds better all round really.
None of you sound very ready for the formality and rules involved, the necessity of appropriate equipment,the health and safety aspects and the team spirit required.

piscesmoon · 17/11/2010 07:39

The other point is that the teacher isn't going to be nasty to the DC because the parents are annoying!
Anyway glad you listened to everyone. Hope DS isn't put off playing.

Chandon · 17/11/2010 07:45

I know it hurts but you were wrong and overly dramatic for pulling him out.

I think it is you who should apologize.

Sorry.

I think your DS would have benefited more from a no-nonsense approach on your side, ie, "it's too bad, I am sorry son, but you are on in the second half and from now on we won't forget the shinpads again'. The teacher could not KNOW you were going to be there with new pads, so he made this, reasonable decision.

DreamTeamGirl · 17/11/2010 10:15

Well done miewie
I know how you can feel SO cross about something and then the next day realise it was a bit silly ....

On the bright side at least you didnt post this in AIBU Grin

Maybe posters could read the whole thread before piling in with criticism????

Welcome to MN

booyhoo · 17/11/2010 10:55

goblinchild i don't think this is a sign that OP's son shouldn't continue with football. for someone who isn't used to playing football and the rules of course it will take time to get the hang of it. for OP footbal is something her ds does for 2 hours once a week but they will soon realise that it is far more to the teacher and will put the effort required into it.

OP take your cues from your son. if he doesn't want to go back then don't make him. although i personally think it would be a shame to waste this good lesson by letting him bow out afetr a bit of embarrasment. it's a lesson we all need to learn how to deal with. if mum/dad let dcs opt out everytime they feel a bit hard done by then it doesn't encourage him to see anything through. a very important life skill IMO.

Littlefish · 17/11/2010 19:26

booyhoo - the OP has come back and said that she realises she over-reacted.

JoanneEmily · 17/11/2010 22:54

Hi!
Just a quick note to say that I also feel like reacting like this sometimes! Although you feel you want an apology I think it best just to let this one go. You're more likely to regret taking it further!

I know loads of people had already replied but just thought I'd say that you are not alone in feeling like this sometimes.

booyhoo · 18/11/2010 00:12

littlefish i don't understand your post.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page