Pressure is getting greater and greater on Primary teachers to run these clubs, for free. One Head near me is well known for asking at interview what clubs you'll run. It's a favourite target for new teachers too to run a club. As I've got older and wiser I've stopped running clubs. It's always the same:
-work another 45min at the end of a long day and still work even longer because of late parents (our school record is 8.15pm to collect a child!!! 5-6pm has also happened a few times). You're left with a tired hungry child you would rather have seen the back of.
-Then you get the ones who hate the club but whose parents have made them go for the few childcare who then piss around the whole time. When they are kicked out their parents always drag them up to you the next day in tears to tell you they love the club really and want to come back, despite weeks of them telling you they hate art/ sport/ drama and them displaying that in class too.
-Don't forget the ones who tell you your club is lacking in some way. Little Johnie expects to use clay next week as art club mainly involves painting (well if anyone did some fundraising we'd have some supplies beyond poster paint and photocopy paper, didn't you here the lead off the roof was nicked again? We have run out of bloody books/ pencils let alone clay/ modrock etc)
-Discipline issues. It's after school so we don't have to behave for the outside provider. So despite getting someone else to do the club you still end up giving your time each week to police it.
-Other logisitcal issues you have, such as no first aider on site (often these are TAs who go home at 3.15) or extra risk assessments/ planning to eat into time.
Even the teachers who like doing clubs get run to the ground by them. Sorry that turned into a rant but after school clubs must be one of the most thankless bits of teaching EVER.
For the record I do still do a few clubs, on a invitation only basis! Now that REALLY winds parents up but it helps me filter out all the kids that don't want to be there.
I must say though I LOVE the parents who volunteer to run clubs and we always support them in doing so and make sure they never have to deal with discipline or other issues to make their lives hard.