Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Preschool education

Get advice from other Mumsnetters to find the best nursery for your child on our Preschool forum.

A little confused about Montessori method

7 replies

sweetieaddict · 02/08/2012 11:54

Am looking at preschool options for DS and am currently reading about the Montessori method.

One question I have is that if the method is child led and children are free to do as they wish, how does this impact at home and regarding other activites outside the nursery environment?

As far as I understand (and do correct me on this if necessary) the children can pick activities to do, so one could play with puzzles every day if they so wished?

I'm a little perplexed as to how this is beneficial to do the same thing all the time rather than doing a wide range of activities. Also, if there is no instruction or guidance (in the traditional sense) is it then harder for them to take instruction outside of the school environment?

Thanks very much

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
teacherlikesapples · 02/08/2012 15:07

I cannot speak in detail about the Montessori method (not a big fan of it myself) but I can give you some more detail on the misconception of self-directed play or free-play as it is often called.

The reason that it is so important in early childhood is of we want children who can think for themselves, are independent, critical thinkers we have to encourage children to make their own choices. If they get to experiment with thinking, ideas and concepts, to use trial and error and be constantly 'actively learning' they are building vital personal skills. Children are not empty vessels waiting to be filled with knowledge.

The ideal scenario is to create self motivated learners- who feel confident and interested to learn about anything and everything. Most people do not thrive in a passive learning (sit still and listen) Most prefer to touch, feel and try. So a fun and relaxed environment where they can "play" makes it safe to learn.

The key for the adults, is to carefully observe and plan the environment, and act as a resource within that environment.

So it might seem that the adults are standing back letting the children do what they like. What might not be obvious is that (in a good nursery) the adults are scaffolding the learning. They may have observed that a child only ever plays with cars, but very rarely ever draws/writes.

So on day one they might set up the cars and the road map carpet. To observe how the child uses them in his play (does he involve others? Does he use language? Does he repeat movements? Use only limited items? A lot can be learnt from even 2-5 minutes of observation.

Day two they might set up the cars and some some paint and paper.- Will this child follow his favourite item to other areas of play (If yes- this opens up a world of scope, if no- back to the drawing board!)

If successful -Day three they might set up the cars, large sheets of paper, pencils, small blocks and examples of road maps & signs. They might sit near by and occasionally say "hmmm I wonder which road I take to get from my house here to nursery." I remember there is a big bendy corner- how would I make show that on my paper?...

Constantly observing and following the child's lead, but planning the equipment & their interaction to extend and support different aspects of the child's development and learning. Often this is the first step for car-mad boys to becoming confident writers. They have the initial sense of achievement and interest some place familiar, then carry that skill to other areas of play.

Because children are developing so many different types of skills at once, to achieve deep level learning they need the opportunity to revisit resources and experiences, so they can test & retest their theories. Consolidating what they are learning. The adults role is to observe, plan and evaluate.

Hopefully someone else can expand on how this works more specifically in a Montessori approach.

Rubirosa · 02/08/2012 15:11

I would say that the Montessori method is probably a little more directed/order than mainstream nursery. Mainstream nursery is also very child-led, and children are able to access and choose their own activities for the majority of their time.

mameulah · 20/08/2012 23:09

OP teacherlikeapples as really done you proud with her answer. There is such a lot of wisdom in her message. The only thing I would add is that (and I have lots of experience teaching different curriculums) it doesn't matter what philosophy the education is based on, it really depends on the quality of interaction that the individual teacher offers. A good teacher will bring out the best of your child regardless of the circumstance (most of the time). A good teacher will provide freedom, choice and questioning that makes your child think rather than simply follow instructions.

usatwinmama · 23/08/2012 05:57

I think you might find this website helpful:
www.montessorianswers.com/misconceptions.html

I'm a big fan of Montessori, and I like that all of the children are not required to do the same thing. Discipline is handled by using education over punishment as much as one reasonably can. I believe when a child is stuck on one activity, the teacher will help guide them to another, maybe by giving choices or something that's not a command but more self-directed to try to get them to make this choice on their own. Here in the States, I'm told that what it means to be a Montessori school can vary widely. There are also different accreditation agencies and not all school recognize certification from all of them.

We currently have our twins in a Montessori parent/toddler class, geared toward the under-3 crowd. Our twins are currently 2. They have a lot of activities throughout the room, each arranged neatly and typically made of natural materials. Each child may choose what they want to do, but they are expected to put away the materials after they are done with it. I'm the only twin mama so I've got a lot of running around the room to do (the parent stays with the child in the class) because often our twins do not play near each other. Sometimes they do. I think toddlers are easy for this since their attention span is so short...or at least for our twins. They are everywhere around the room and exploring easily a range of activities and both love their cars.

The twins are also in a cooperative 2's class based on the Creative Curriculum so I'm curious to see how this is different when I observe them some days in the classroom with this (other days I will not be there). I've had them in daycare a couple mornings a week this past summer to prepare them for Mama not being around and it's ok for them to be somewhere and Mama will come back a couple hours later.

Apri · 29/08/2012 04:14

so it is the matter of staff not the method really?

camdancer · 29/08/2012 08:12

Good preschool staff will have looked at all different methods and will include the good practice from anywhere. They won't be confined by a single method.

One thing to be aware of is that the word "Montessori" is not protected in any way, so anyone can say they are running a Montessori nursery. You really need to look at the actual qualifications the staff have rather than just the name.

TiggyD · 02/09/2012 10:18

"I'm a little perplexed as to how this is beneficial to do the same thing all the time rather than doing a wide range of activities."
If a child is engaged in an activity they are learning. There's no need to stop them learning with the thing they're interested in the most to something they're less interested in. They'll move on themselves when they feel they've stopped learning.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread