Please help with baby name!! So indecisive

[teatime2022]

Our choices so far :

Theodora
Teddie (rather than Theodora as a full name)
Penelope
Hazel
Violet
Ada
Lyla

middle name likely to be Elizabeth or Florence

Surname one syllable beginning with H

I know so many people with children called Ada now that although it's nice I'd be worried she'd be one of 3 Ada's at school.
Theodora I think is nice, I know a girl called Dora for short and it's quite sweet but actually Thea seems really nice too.
The fav for me is actually your middle name choice Florence, I also know a Flora both are lovely names.

Penelope Florence. Penny or Nell for short.

Hazel is my favourite. Have you heard of Violet Elizabeth from the Just William books? That would put me off Violet.

Theodora - i'd go Thea
Teddie - no
Penelope - no
Hazel - love it
Violet - love it
Ada - no
Lyla - meh

@BadBarry yep Ada is becoming increasingly popular which is putting me off slightly, but I feel all those names are floating within the top 100 somewhere, they’re not overly unique! I would love to use Florence as a first name but my partner isn’t keen, it was my great grandmas name!!

How about
Matilda (nn Tilda) Florence

Teddie is fine as a nickname but not on its own as a name for a little girl in my opinion. Dora is the most obvious nickname for Theodora for a girl in my opinion. Or you could have Dotty.
Like all the others just fine to be honest.
Penelope perhaps my favourite.

Strongly dislike Penelope and violet. Best is Ada.

Penelope, it was on my girls name list!

I love the name Hazel!

Violet Lyla or Lyla Violet

Violet :-)