I was pregnant and planned to deliver at the hospital closest to me which is 5 minutes from home and probably one of the better hospitals in town.
However I sadly had a miscarriage and ended up getting treatment at a different and smaller hospital further away as my Dr at hospital 1 was not willing to perform erpc. DH and I really liked the Dr who looked after me at hospital 2 and if I got pregnant again I'd love to see her for ante natal care and deliver the baby with her (we live overseas so choose a consultant and pay privately).
How far is your hospital? This smaller one would be half an hour in rush hour, 45 minutes on a really bad day. Would that be too far? I'm also not sure if it would be irresponsible to choose to give birth in a smaller hospital which may not have such good facilities.
I'm a bit against hospital 1 also because it was where we found out our baby had died and MIL died there last year so right now it doesn't seem like a good place for us.
Sorry for rambling. This is all so hypothetical right now.