I'm happy to say which nappies we had but what works for us won't necessarily be best for you. I'm not even sure now that I would go for the same again if I was staying over. Someone suggested doing the Nappy Lady questionnaire and I would definitely agree with that. I didn't know about it when I picked but did it later and bought some extras.
My criteria were cotton next to the skin (I have allergies and I know that can run in the family), plain white so they don't show through clothes, and some flexibility to adapt and change how they are used if I have problems. I didn't mind if they take some practice to get used to.
I got a Bambino Mio birth to potty prefolds pack as it met my criteria and Amazon had an open box one with a third off. I also bought a Bambino Mio newborn pack on eBay, second hand and open but unused as they don't sell them any more and I wanted some to use if the baby was small or if the others made clothes too bulky.
That was fine initially and I got a nice fold that worked for us and later made a few additions to sit our needs. DS was a heavy wetting boy with an hourglass figure (big round bottom, tiny waist and huge ribs) and jet propelled bowels that shot poo out in an alarming manner.
Extras I got included:
nappy nippers and pins to keep the wings of the poo catching fold tight closed
hemp boosters as they were slimmer, more absorbent, less prone to crush leaks and felt nicer than the ones in my kit (I got hemp fleece breast pads from the same company and loved them too, so soothing when they have absorbed a little milk)
Twelve terries and handknit soaker for breathability overnight- I wouldn't want to sleep 12 hours with my bottom in a plastic bag! This helped his nappy rash until it disappeared when he got the right medication dose for his acid reflux
5 bumgenius elemental. These don't hold much fluid but are great for outfits that otherwise wouldn't accommodate a cloth nappy. I would say that they are amaller when wet than a wet disposable which always makes DS look like hens wearing a codpiece!
Good luck choosing!