Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Pregnancy

Talk about every stage of pregnancy, from early symptoms to preparing for birth.

Am I unreasonable to want a mature midwife who's had children?

45 replies

bobthetomato · 04/06/2015 23:07

First of all, I don't at all mean to insult all those highly-capable, hardworking, well-trained young midwives out there.

They are doing an excellent and vital job.

I'm just having a hormonal rant here.

With my first three pregnancies, the midwives I had were all older than me, and each of them had had children themselves. We had an excellent rapport, and they were able to speak to me from a place of shared experience. They were absolutely wonderful.

However, now with my fourth, perhaps because nine years have passed since my first pregnancy, every single midwife I've met (three so far) is almost young enough to be my own daughter. None of them have birthed children yet.

They have been lovely, professional, and kind, but I just feel unable to connect with them. Today I met two of them at the same time, and tried to talk through some of my apprehensions concerning my meeting with my consultant gynaecologist, who I feel is pushing me down a more medicalised route than I want.

They listened, but I just felt there was no real understanding of what I was trying to share.

It could just be a personality thing, and the fact that they are so young and haven't experienced pregnancy might have nothing to do with the fact that I'm failing to connect and communicate, and that I feel a lack of support and sympathy.

Having said that, the midwife who delivered my third baby hadn't had children either, and she was phenomenal. I couldn't have asked for anyone better.

So my issue isn't so much with the ones who help with the birth, but with the antenatal care, when I just want someone to talk to. Perhaps I just have an overly romanticised idea of the midwife as an older wise woman, a mentor almost, leading others down a path which she has travelled herself.

Am I unreasonable? Silly? Unfair? Ageist? Hormonal? Or all of the above?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
juliet111111 · 06/06/2015 02:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Glastokitty · 06/06/2015 02:44

You're being daft, but I guess you know that. Smile. When I had my son I was very ill and ended up in HDU where the head nurse looked about 12 and had no children, she was absolutely amazing with all the mums and babies, I swear she was like a baby whisperer!

ReallyTired · 06/06/2015 03:06

No you are being unreasonable.

Believe it or not, it is the mother who does the work of delivering the baby not the health professionals. It is the mother who should take credit for the miracle of growing a baby for nine months and giving birth. The term "midwife" means with woman. It is a support role.

Experiences of pregnancy, labour and parenting are different for every woman. The fact that I had two easy childbirth experiences might make me less empathic to some who ends up needing a c section. I might not appreciate the disappointment of not having the natural childbirth experience or why someone might feel cheated. Certainly there are a couple of really stupid women who unable to out themselves in someone else's shoes.

You need someone who knows how to save your life if something goes wrong. It's important that they understand the cascade of intervention, but know when it is appriopiate. They need to have the ability to keep calm, empower you so you can make decisions about your care.

Suitable people for midwifery can be young, old, black or white or even male! The knowledge and personal qualities of a midwife are more important than whether they had children.

crazytyke · 06/06/2015 08:09

Why are you stalking your midwives on Facebook?

Bue · 06/06/2015 10:43

OP I get you, and I am myself a midwife currently 32 weeks pregnant with my first (I'm 35). For myself I much prefer an older, more experienced midwife. I am actually much less fussed about whether or not they have children but especially for antenatal care I gravitate towards that life experience. The idea of midwife as wise woman, as you say! Interestingly as a student I always preferred having older mentors too and I know a lot of other students did too.

OhEmGeee · 06/06/2015 18:09

Bluepetra you looked up your midwives on fb? Are they not allowed a social life outside of work? You are being utterly ridiculous.

Bluepetra · 06/06/2015 18:36

Yes, i have a friend who is a friend of one midwife in my area, so yea, I looked as I was shocked just how immature she seemed for such a responsible job. Nothing wrong in that. Glad I've swapped anyway, put my own mind at rest.

MellieFitz · 06/06/2015 18:42

Best midwife I had was a man. He was fab, didn't talk to me like I was a piece of shit like the women Hmm

PomeralLights · 06/06/2015 19:19

Haha how immature she seemed for such a responsible job....have you ever met any consultants or surgeons socially? I'm guessing you'd never go inside a hospital again!

SoupDragon · 06/06/2015 19:30

Would you only want a heart surgeon who had suffered from heart disease?

OhEmGeee · 06/06/2015 19:46

But what has what she gets up to her in own time got to do with how she performs in her job?

Bluepetra · 06/06/2015 19:49

I'm happy with my decision and yes that's how I feel. So what, get over it. Boring now.

OhEmGeee · 06/06/2015 20:18

It's an internet forum, we can talk about it as much as we like. You don't get to decide that.

sausagedogsrus · 06/06/2015 20:42

I have no idea whether my midwife has children or not. It never occurred to me to ask.

NorbertDentressangle · 06/06/2015 20:48

I think it's very much down to the individual personalities TBH.

Although saying that I have a friend who was a midwife - after she had her first child she said she was embarrassed when she thought back to things she'd said to women who were giving birth.

imwithspud · 06/06/2015 21:20

I'm interested on where you'd stand when it comes to male midwives?

I much prefer the midwife I had through the second half of my pregnancy with DC2, she's slightly older than me and has a DC roughly the same age as my DC1, but I don't think that's really relevant. I like the fact that she's friendly and approachable and genuinely seems interested in getting to know me and what I have to say. I'd definitely put that down to her personality and general demeanour rather than the fact that she happens to have a child. I had two different midwives before we moved areas and neither really gave off the same vibes, although I only met the second midwife once so I didn't really have much of a chance to get to know her. I had a student and an older midwife helping me deliver DC2 and both were fantastic despite having different levels of experience - couldn't tell you whether they had children of their own or not as it never really came up.

You are being unreasonable imo, it sounds more like a personality clash more than anything. Sometimes you just don't 'gel' with people.

OhEmGeee · 06/06/2015 21:46

I had a male mw see me after I gave birth, he was brilliant.

Roseybee10 · 06/06/2015 22:18

Wow I have the odd drink now and then and daft night out and I'm a teacher. I hope that doesn't mean I'm not responsible enough to have that kind of job. I realise most people think people in those kinds of jobs are just their job title and nothing else but at the end of the day it's only a small part of who they are as a person.

Glastokitty · 07/06/2015 13:04

Oops, I lived in Hounslow 22 years ago, not 29 if it makes any difference. And while it may have gentrified or got nicer since then, it's still at the arse end of the Piccadilly line iirc, so commuting to the city must still be a pain. The flight path thing is an annoyance too. I am biased though, I only lived there for three months and got mugged, before moving to the relative calm of Stockwell. Grin

Glastokitty · 07/06/2015 13:04

Oh ffs wrong thread.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread