I had a home birth a week ago. It was my first so nothing to compare it to.
It was mostly lovely.
I'm in the States so had no pain relief or air. It was painful but I now feel like I've climbed Everest and am incredibly proud of myself.
Don't get me wrong, I was screaming for it at the time!
The pool took bloody ages to fill, we left it too late. I'd have liked something squisher as my knees hurt!
I will say that although I knew something was up at the time it wasn't until I read the birth notes yesterday that ds was really not in a good way. I pushed for 6 hours and he'd pooped inside so went my waters broke and his heart rate dropped the midwives got worried and were very stern with me to get him out immediately. Then they had to resuscitate him when he came out.
I was a good hours life flight from a hospital so they decided to deal with whatever came at home but if they couldn't have resuscitated him I'd never have forgiven myself.
But then they did, it was fine and who knows how it could have gone differently in a hospital with such high intervention rates.
Also I had quite a big bleed which looking back if it hadn't stopped in the end I probably would have been screwed.
So on reflection, I'd do it at home again but make sure I was nearer a hospital.
Really, with the pain, you can get into such a zone at home as it's so quiet and familiar it's more than possible to deal with it. For me anyway.
The best bit was the midwives making us a meal, helping me go to the bathroom, tucking me up in bed and leaving.