I'm finding this thread fascinating.
I'm not at all a witch, but over the last few years my husband has been getting in to druidry and reading books on magic. I'm finding his new interest confusing as it seems to have come from nowhere and be at odds with what I felt his approach was in the past.
It's kind of disorientating to have your life partner suddenly wanting to 'bless' things and talking about an altar in the garden. I find it confusing and almost a little bit scary as I don't understand any of it and it all sounds very alien to me.
But some of the things you talk about in this thread I have a natural interest in, for example being in nature, enjoying fragrance, herbs, understanding moon cycles and how they affect my mood. And I'm interested in the red tent idea (though might not be understanding what it's really about - I'm reading it as an opportunity to get together with other women).
Where I get confused though - is this not just enjoying being human? Don't all humans benefit from wonderful natural smells and being in nature and a better understanding of themselves as animal creatures? Don't we all appreciate flowers and herbs? And coming together (friends, families) for ceremonies (e.g. celebrations)? I could totally imagine myself living in a little wooden hut in a forest and making natural perfumes by candlelight. But does this have to be a witchy thing?
I think the bit that goes too far for me is the 'spell' stuff - I just can't believe in it and it sounds too eeby jeeby and made up (to me). But I do believe in sending out good feelings and positive energy. Perhaps it is the same thing but we're just calling it different names I don't know?