Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Philosophy/religion

Join our Philosophy forum to discuss religion and spirituality.

Do you insist on saying Grace when it's just you?

4 replies

PatterofaMinion · 22/02/2015 09:49

I am of course grateful for what we eat and I have a half and half belief system, which doesn't sound great I know but I suppose after many years I'm still agnostic.

I don't go to church, or say Grace, or ever pray out loud.

My mother is very Catholic and the other day said a sort of Grace when we were having a casual lunch - despite the fact that it was just me and her in the room, and children who weren't listening.

I wasn't sure why she did it. I know that if there is a God, he can probably hear her thoughts anyway, so why would someone want to do it so that I could hear it too? Tbh it made me a bit cross as she can take things a bit far regarding religion and it crosses over into obsessive-compulsive on occasion. Also I felt as though she was being contentious and/or trying to prove something, ie making some sort of point.

But maybe I am wrong. Is this something that is important to do - to bear witness as it were, in this manner? Hope someone can set me straight.

OP posts:
bigbluestars · 22/02/2015 10:38

Well there is not god, so grace is just a casual muttering to me.
My mother says grace, but I just ignore her and sart eating anyway. It's rude to stop people tucking into a meal when they are hungry.

PatterofaMinion · 22/02/2015 13:38

Well she didn't stop me eating...she just sort of said thank you for this lunch, and I said I didn't make it, (as she had brought it with her) and she said she was just thanking God.

I mean yes, that's lovely, but to do it so ostentatiously felt like it wasn't necessary. It felt like she was trying to make a point. I'm not sure what point though.

OP posts:
niminypiminy · 22/02/2015 15:25

We say grace as a family, and I say it silently if I am eating on my own. Even if you have no faith (though I do) it can be good to make time for all that you have and to think of those who have less. You might take a look at the lovely Daily Gratitudes thread for ideas. Saying grace before meals is a ritualised way of being grateful that we have good to eat - often we need rituals to make us rember to do something, like brushing teeth, doing pelvic floor exercises, phoning your parents at a particular time ... We all have them. Grace needn't be a prayer (though obviously for Christians it will be). It can just be a moment when you say 'thank you' for all that you have.

niminypiminy · 22/02/2015 15:27

(Sorry for spelling and grammar - on phone -I meant saying grace is a way of saying thank you and showing gratitude that we have good things to eat, and remembering those who haven't.)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread