Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Pets

Join our community on the Pet forum to discuss anything related to pets.

Took in dog, then gave back to original owners

45 replies

SnappyPinkDog · 17/06/2024 19:33

Hi all,
I am just looking to vent here. Would welcome any support.
Me and my other half took in a GSD as we had seen that she was being rehomed. On the advert, she was labelled as loving, affectionate and also food-oriented.
We had seen her and she was super loving, and just a general all-round good girl, could do no wrong. My other half had previously had dogs, just not as big as a GSD. We had gone through the research and it seemed like it was the right way to go. He did say we should trial his family dog (cockapoo) just to see if it would work with me as I never had a dog before, but I said no and said I have thought this through.
We picked her up and it was great for the first night, then I had a mental breakdown. We live in a new build home and everything is still new. I had compromised with my other half and said she can sit on sofa etc. however, soon, the smell started to get a bit much (it was mostly from her bed). And her shedding, which we thought we could keep under control with grooming. There was hair everywhere, all over the hallway, kitchen living room. She spilled water everywhere and is a messy eater. I understand these are just doggy things, however, coming from a household that didn't ever have dogs, it was a culture shock.
My anxiety skyrocketed and I realised it's actually 'puppy blues'. I started resenting her and not showing her the love and affection she needed and had a breakdown to the point where my other half was anxious to get home from work. I couldn't eat, sleep nor practice basic hygiene, and barely had enough energy to get out of bed. I already suffer from a bit of ill mental health and I think this exacerbated it, considering it took me a long journey to get accustomed to living without family and with my other half in our new home.
I became too anxious to walk her, which she felt as dogs know these things, because she was reactive to other dogs. I was scared as well, because she was super loving at home, but then really reactive when it came to walks. She lunged and it took me and my other half to hold her back but it seemed not enough sometimes. At one point, we feared she would break through a fence that was separating us and another owner with two GSDs (who weren't barking and were super well behaved). I understand this would come with training, but it came as a shock to my system. If I had to let her out on a walk, I would pray and worry to not see another dog around so she wouldn't go crazy. We didn't know this at all and it wasn't mentioned in the advert at all - we truly believed that she was a calm, lazy and treat-loving GSD dog from everything we saw in her own home and in ours, even as she used to live with another GSD with the current owners, so we believed she was fine with other dogs. This is why we went for her, as she ticked all of our boxes.
I had gone to work on the 4th day and it was okay, came to her and she was excited and a really good well behaved dog. I gave her lots of love, however in the evening, I couldn't handle it again, so there was another breakdown and a panic attack. After a long discussion, my other half told me straight up that I was not ready to have this dog and it's not fair when I am cold to her and take out my frustration by withholding her affection. She also ran through the house with muddy paws on our carpets as our garden is not yet sorted (just soil and mud if it rains), which again, is doggy things, but had really triggered me.
Although we both loved her tremendously and she is the best dog, and through no fault of her own at all, my other half made the decision to call her previous owner and arrange for the dog to go back. They were understanding and we explained everything, even on the day we were picking her up, the owners said they will take her back if she's not a right fit, they clearly care about where she goes. We had a lengthy talk about the 'what ifs' and my other half is truly a rock for supporting me the way he does, even almost contemplating getting her back. But we knew that wouldn't be right, it was stressful enough as it was for her to grow accustomed to us and it wouldn't be fair to keep taking her back and forth.
I've been a mess, but I felt relief when she had been picked up last night. The house is quiet again, and it's just me and my other half. It was a tough lesson to learn, and it had to be done. We hope she goes to a home that will love her as much as we did, even more so. We are both still young (24, 25) and this felt like a rushed decision in hindsight, but it was a real eye opener for me and I understand what it entails to own a dog, and might consider a different breed when we are both 100% ready in a couple of years.

OP posts:
TheShellBeach · 17/06/2024 20:38

I couldn't eat, sleep nor practice basic hygiene, and barely had enough energy to get out of bed

FFS you only had her for four days!
🤣

Countrygirlxo · 17/06/2024 20:39

Wow. Just wow. Do you realize how pathetic you sound??
That poor dog.

Toddlerteaplease · 17/06/2024 20:39

Get a grip, and never get another pet.

Daveismyhero · 17/06/2024 20:40

As an experienced GSD owner, they are not always a good fit for first time owners yiu have ti research the breeding lines very carefully to find one that's a good fit for your needs. However, just because cockapoos don't shed doesnt mean they're clean dogs. Ours spends just as much time rolling around in the mud as our shepherd does and she has less spacial awareness than he does so even though she's a quarter of the size she's 3 times as annoying 😂 it doesnt sound like you'll ever be able to cope with a pet

Killingoffmyflowersonebyone · 17/06/2024 20:40

Not sure if you want sympathy, OP. But you won’t get it.

Don’t EVER get another dog, OP. You clearly did not bloody research to have thought that you (as a first time owner) and your partner (clearly not owned dogs as an adult because if he had he wouldn’t have chosen a random GSD of someone random person) would be a good fit for a dog that is NOT suitable for novice owners.

Giving up after four day. Pah!

Count yourself lucky it wasn’t aggressive - or you might be telling a very different story.

Edit; just seen this gem in the OP

We hope she goes to a home that will love her as much as we did, even more so.

You had her four days and gave her up. You didn’t love her.

Listress · 17/06/2024 20:44

That was a crazy 96 hours OP! You’ll need to lie down in a dark room to recover for a few days. I actually can’t believe what a I’ve just read. Please never ever get another dog and think very carefully before having children as they’re not as easy to hand back.

mnahmnah · 17/06/2024 20:44

I’m astonished that it didn’t occur to you that when your garden is just mud and soil, that the dog would therefore drag that into the house. Did you think it would wipe its feet on the way in? Or not go in the garden?

Clearly not enough research or common sense. It’s an animal, a big one, that slobbers and has lots of hair and energy. Pretty obvious really.

Tel12 · 17/06/2024 20:45

For everyone's sake please don't consider getting any other pets.

DietCokeandHulaHoops · 17/06/2024 20:48

Erm What support late you looking for.

You stupidly got a dog, acted hugely dramatic about it and then handed it back.
Should we form a support group?

LondonFox · 17/06/2024 20:48

bikeylikey · 17/06/2024 19:44

Jesus you sound like hard work.

You gave the dog back after four days. She barely had time to settle in.

Never take on another dog, you're clearly too fragile. 🙄

Oh please.
Unless someone is experienced dog owner with big dogs and adult dog adoption, getting an adult GSD is a bad choice.
GSD is not a dog for a first time owner.
It is not a dog to be adopted as adult lightly.

OP, hope you learned. Tbh at your age maybe start planning for a baby as it will probably be on your radar in few years and harder to do with an old dog. Speaking from experience.

If you ereally want a dog, now you know how much work they can brung. There are smaller and easier dogs but keep in mind shedding, muddy paws, mess, barking etc.

sandyhappypeople · 17/06/2024 20:53

For info OP, dogs pick up on your anxiety, if you are out walking them and you are a nervous wreck, they think there is something to be scared of and it makes them act a nervous wreck too, it's not the dogs fault. With your debilitating anxiety and the fact she was with a new family and not knowing what is going on, you wouldn't be able to tell anything about her long term behaviour after such a short time.

She'll be fine with the right owners.

In the kindest possible way you are 100% not cut out for dog ownership, instead of looking at what the dog can offer you ("ticking all your boxes" etc), you should be looking at what YOU can offer a dog, a rescue dog needs you to be even more patient, calm and understanding. You don't have anything to offer a dog so you should never consider getting one again.

BluebellsareBlue · 17/06/2024 21:07

FOUR DAYS?!? That poor dog has had a lucky escape. Mental breakdowns over mud? Jesus, please don't ever get another dog, you aren't mature enough to have one

BluebellsareBlue · 17/06/2024 21:09

Daveismyhero · 17/06/2024 20:40

As an experienced GSD owner, they are not always a good fit for first time owners yiu have ti research the breeding lines very carefully to find one that's a good fit for your needs. However, just because cockapoos don't shed doesnt mean they're clean dogs. Ours spends just as much time rolling around in the mud as our shepherd does and she has less spacial awareness than he does so even though she's a quarter of the size she's 3 times as annoying 😂 it doesnt sound like you'll ever be able to cope with a pet

Same, experienced GSD owner here with a beagle 'ish' rescue. Beagley type is the pain in the arse even though half the size of my lot!!

Pumpituppump · 17/06/2024 21:16

You are beyond stupid. You couldn’t cope with a dog behaving like a dog. Poor dog had a lucky escape.

Sue152 · 17/06/2024 21:25

I don't think you should have another dog, you can't just have them and then when you get sick of them give them back. They're an animal not a toy. Dogs get dirty, smell and are hairy. A GSD was a terrible idea for a first dog so I don't know what research you did.

Puppies and babies are even harder by the way.

Giantpaw · 17/06/2024 21:40

Some people cope with life and some don’t I suppose.

If your this uptight about everything, rethink any pets or children in the future. Life’s not meant to be this hard!

lovemycbf · 17/06/2024 21:51

I don't think you getting another dog in the future would be a good idea at all.
Owning a dog big or small Is a big commitment and yes it takes over your life but when you enjoy owning a dog it's not an issue
And blaming your young age isn't an excuse in any way

movingonsaturday · 18/06/2024 02:50

Don't have a baby either 😉

flashspeed · 22/06/2024 00:50

OP will probably be fine with a different breed, gsds are a very serious breed unless you luck out with a laidback one. They will bark at strangers, are horrible until they reach about 4, and are nicknamed german shedders by enthusiasts. OP would be fine with a nice little companion breed and could enjoy owning it. The dog obviously had flaws if they had another gsd at home but chose to rehome this one.

BluebellsareBlue · 26/06/2024 20:59

flashspeed · 22/06/2024 00:50

OP will probably be fine with a different breed, gsds are a very serious breed unless you luck out with a laidback one. They will bark at strangers, are horrible until they reach about 4, and are nicknamed german shedders by enthusiasts. OP would be fine with a nice little companion breed and could enjoy owning it. The dog obviously had flaws if they had another gsd at home but chose to rehome this one.

Where are you getting the dog was flawed because they had another GSD? That's just you making stuff up I'm afraid. The OP should NOT have an animal as she's clearly highly strung if she had a
Mental breakdown after one night with a dog!!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread