Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Pets

Join our community on the Pet forum to discuss anything related to pets.

Can fish really *vanish*??

7 replies

thebluefoxategreensocks · 31/10/2007 16:27

In November of last year we decided to get some fish for our daughter's first birthday. I got one of these small 10 litre plastic tank kits and bought 2 goldfish and a Zebra Dano. They had one incident of Ick about 9 months ago but other than that have been happy & healthy. We'd only ever gone away for weekends since getting them and I'd always bought these small weekend feeder blocks which usually had a fair bit left of them over a week later, but they did eat off bits off it.

Well...we're just back from a 2 week holiday to USA and I bought a different block feeder, seashell shape which should feed a number of fish for 2 weeks, so I thought it would quite happily do my three small fish.

However...I came home to find (much to our horror!) one lonely fish (the largest of them all, a big orange gold fish), and NO sign at all of the smaller gold fish or the Zebra dano.

Can gold fish become canablistic and eat their friends? The block feeder still looks totally uneaten and has been in the tank for over 3 weeks now, so I wonder if it was faulty and they got hungry and the biggest survived on the smaller ones? Or....did the others just become ill and die and he ate them? I do wonder if they had insufficent oxygen, as my small filter/pump died the weekend before we left and the new one I bought didn't airate it at all.

Any ideas? There was NO sign at all of there ever having been other fish - not even bits and pieces of dead fish, so I'm totally mystified! Just didn't think such a thing could happen. I'd have thought I might at least come home to find floating fish, but not nothing at all. Very confused!

OP posts:
AnAngelWithin · 31/10/2007 16:29

yep we had this with our danio. if the little ones get sick then it doesnt take much for the big ones to get rid of them

IamDaisy · 31/10/2007 16:30

I think yoou have one full, but lonely fish, LOL!

Yes the big ones will eat the smaller ones...check out the ingredients on your fish food tub....fish, fish and more fish unfortunately!

chopsterHeadsOffEverybody · 31/10/2007 16:32

sorry but this did make me giggle a bit. Yes they will eat each ohter, it is very common. Anything which will fit in their mouth will go straight in, or even piece by piece. as my larger breeds of fish have grown, the smallest eventually all got eaten.

thebluefoxategreensocks · 31/10/2007 16:36

So am I safe to buy more fish? I'm upgrading to a big 45 litre tank and wanting to get quite a few more fish, but I'd hate to think he would eat them all up! He's only about 2.5 inches long at most, so it's not like he's huge! He's never done anything nasty before, though maybe sometimes he did chase the other one about slightly, but nothing that even suggested really he was a bully.

Do I need to dump him, or you think he's safe as long as I don't have ill fish again?

OP posts:
beautifulgirls · 31/10/2007 16:38

Yep - the most likely thing is that the bodies of the other two were eaten by the big fish. Sorry
If you ever have a situation without the airation working for a while make sure as a minimum you leave the lid off the tank so at least the top layers of water are relatively oxygenated until you can get a new pump working.
The feeder blocks are usually ok for feeding while you are away, especially with a small number of fish. It may be slower to dissolve than usual because presumably without the air system working the filtration in the tank has been zero too while you have been away.

chopsterHeadsOffEverybody · 31/10/2007 16:42

be careful about leaving the lid off, some fish are jumpers.

fish gettign eaten is part and patcel of keeping them, so it prob wont be the last time it happens. Try to get more fish of a similar size, don't overstock your tank and then it's jsut trial and error. Some fish jsut don't get on, like people!

thebluefoxategreensocks · 31/10/2007 23:05

thanks for the replies

I've already ordered a new air pump in addition to the Fluval filter I've already had installed - will definantely wait till it's all set up properly before adding any fish! So hopefully with a separate air pump they should get lots of oxygen. The lid was totally closed for the 2 weeks I was away (and never opened for anything, obviously!), so I guess with only the filter circulating the water and no air pump bringing fresh air in, I presume there just wasn't enough oxygen to keep the three of them alive. Poor things! I did ask the pet shop when I bought the filter (last minute thing before going away, since it quit on me just days before leaving!) if the filter would airate it as well and she said yes, but there's nothing in the instruction paper or anything, and it certainly doesn't have an air hose like my small Elite Mini did, and adds no bubbles or anything to the water, so I guess they were just oxygen starved, and that prob made it more difficult for the feeder block to dissove as well. Guess you sometimes learn things the hard way. Oh well. I will certainly know for future!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread