Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Pedants' corner

Can good be used as a singular noun in this context?

22 replies

ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 21:47

Today Friday 19 June Ritullah Shah writes in The Thunderer Column of The Times about the BBC being a public good. My query is can good be a singular noun? It sounds clumsy and I think good as a noun does not have a singular.
Your opinion please

OP posts:
Redflagsabounded · 19/06/2026 21:48

I thinks it sounds awkward but okay. 'the public good' is reasonably common and also singular.

LittleBearPad · 19/06/2026 21:50

Yes it can.

Wigeon · 19/06/2026 21:50

I go running for the good of my health

She started a charity for the common good

I gave my teenager a curfew for their own good

So, yes.

ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 21:50

Public good means a crowd.

OP posts:
ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 21:52

@Wigeon , Are they all nouns?

OP posts:
Wigeon · 19/06/2026 21:52

I can't think of a sentence where "the public good" would mean a crowd. I don't think it does.

Wigeon · 19/06/2026 21:53

ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 21:52

@Wigeon , Are they all nouns?

Yes

Can good be used as a singular noun in this context?
ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 21:56

The public is more than one person, is how I was thinking.

OP posts:
ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 21:58

It annoys me when they try and make it singular in 'goods and services'

OP posts:
ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 22:01

Thanks @Wigeon and others. I now know.
But I still think her phrase would have been better if she had said benefit.

OP posts:
BacksToTheFuture · 19/06/2026 22:02

ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 21:50

Public good means a crowd.

No it doesn't it means for the good of the public

ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 22:04

@BacksToTheFuture Eh? Not for the good of the public?

OP posts:
maudelovesharold · 19/06/2026 22:17

I don’t think describing the BBC as ‘a public good’ is correct usage at all. An organisation can exist in the interest of the public good, but it can’t be a public good. That doesn’t make sense. In other uses where ‘good’ is a noun - the good of my health/his own good/the common good, it is prefaced by a dynamic verb - I run for/he gave up smoking for/he acted for. The BBC is a public good sounds really clunky. The BBC is a public asset, I would say.

WhereAreWeNow · 19/06/2026 22:26

Sounds fine to me.

MyThreeWords · 19/06/2026 22:39

This is an extremely common usage, especially in economics. Its been around forever. it means an institution or service that is for the benefit of people in general - i.e. no one is excluded from benefiting from it - and is generally funded by taxation rather than by profit-seeking mechanisms.

There isn't anything ungrammatical about it. It just sounds strange to you because you are unfamiliar with it. Perhaps you think it is a new expression and that is what antagonises you? But it isn't at all new.

Pearlstillsinging · 19/06/2026 22:46

ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 21:56

The public is more than one person, is how I was thinking.

The public is a singular noun meaning several people. The public good is a singular noun qualified by the adjective public.
And what about 'The good, the bad and the ugly'?

ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 22:47

I question you use of antagonise @MyThreeWords .

OP posts:
ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 22:49

The good, the bad, and the ugly. 😉

OP posts:
Tryingtokeepgoing · 19/06/2026 22:52

MyThreeWords · 19/06/2026 22:39

This is an extremely common usage, especially in economics. Its been around forever. it means an institution or service that is for the benefit of people in general - i.e. no one is excluded from benefiting from it - and is generally funded by taxation rather than by profit-seeking mechanisms.

There isn't anything ungrammatical about it. It just sounds strange to you because you are unfamiliar with it. Perhaps you think it is a new expression and that is what antagonises you? But it isn't at all new.

Indeed…that’s what I learned at school way back in the ‘80s. GCSE economics!

MyThreeWords · 19/06/2026 23:03

I suppose it is a bit quirky that we tend not to refer to private goods in the singular; whereas we often do with public goods. Perhaps that is because public goods are more likely to be large-scale singular pieces of infrastructure or amenity like "the road system" or "clean air" or "the BBC" -- rather than boringly multiple things like apples or biscuits.

BrickBiscuit · 21/06/2026 01:18

ThatsNicer · 19/06/2026 21:56

The public is more than one person, is how I was thinking.

The public, the audience, the aristocracy, the team, the population - all singular nouns with more than one person.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page