Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Pedants' corner

"Please may you"

28 replies

GurbangulyJones · 07/08/2025 00:18

Where the heck is this coming from? Is it just me who is hearing this more frequently? "Please may I" is fine of course but what's wrong with "please would you?" or "please could you?"
It doesn't really make sense, I don't think, in that "may" is asking for permission - one could ask in the first or third person for permission but it just doesn't work in the second person.
Feel free to criticise the grammar or punctuation in my post, there's a lot of it and it's late at night but you get the general point I hope. Language evolves etc etc but I just can't quite square this one!

OP posts:
alongtimeagoandfaraway · 16/05/2026 06:30

I worked with an Oxford professor who did this - probably still does. I tried to explain and it worked for a bit but then ‘may you’ restarted. Drove me mad.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 16/05/2026 07:59

ScrollingLeaves · 17/10/2025 23:49

‘May you live a long time.’
’Long may you be happy together.’

I know this sort of use of may with you is correct but can’t think why.

It's because it's the subjunctive mood which is used for wishes, amongst other things. I suppose that in this sense 'may you sit on the carpet' or 'may you work from the other office today' aren't entirely wrong, as they convey the speaker's fervent desire that the thing should happen, but I doubt that that's what they meant to tell you. In any case prefacing it with 'please' makes no sense at all.

upinaballoon · 16/05/2026 14:11

HoppityBun · 15/05/2026 23:00

Surely you may do so, but you might not?

A woman once said that she didn't know when to say 'I' and when to say 'me'. I could have answered her on that one.

Similarly, I don't know when to use 'may' and when to use 'might'. A lesson is welcome.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page