Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Fans of 'How to talk so your kids will listen...' - come and convince me

29 replies

becstarlitsea · 29/07/2009 09:28

... that it could work for my DS. I bought it after being recommended it on MN when I was struggling with DSs behaviour, but I can't recognise my DS in the scenarios at all and am really sceptical about how to apply it, or whether I should pick and choose a few bits and try them, and if so, which ones. My DS is 3.

It seems like I'm reading about kids who easily get discouraged or worry about what their Mum thinks/feels. It also seems like it's talking about kids who don't usually tell you all about how they feel, and what's going on for them. DS never, ever, ever shuts up and tells us every single thought that crosses his mind. (DH saw what I was reading and inquired if there's another book called 'How to get your kids will shut the fuck up for five seconds so you can get an occasional word in edgewise')

EG yesterday - Scenario - I'm running a fever with swine flu, have been stuck inside in tiny flat with DS all day, he's been IM-POSS-IB-LE and his latest trick is to take a 2 litre bottle of water out of the fridge, take it into the living room and pour the whole bottle on the floor, while I was in the bathroom cleaning up wee from where he peed all over the towels on the rail.

'DS you poured water all over the floor on purpose didn't you?'
'Sorry Mum'
'Please could you clean it up for me?'
'No, because I'm playing with my fire engine, I'm too busy'
'DS please, help me out here.'
'Mum, are you sad?'
'Yes, I am a bit, I've got a lot on this evening, and now there's water all over the floor and I'd really like you to clean it up. And you're not sorry you did it, are you?'
'I said 'sorry''
'Did you mean it?'
'No not really, I'm happy playing with my fire engine. Would you like a kiss Mum?'
'No, I want you to clean up the water!'
'Mum, don't worry. Just clean it up now and then make my dinner.'

So tell me. Is this really the right book for me? And if so, how???

PS the scenario above did not end in violence, and for that I congratulate myself. Some days my highest achievement is not strangling him...

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
doggiesayswoof · 29/07/2009 11:41

franklymydear that does sound like one of the "how NOT to do it" examples from the book tbh

bec I am full of admiration at how you handled your boy

I would have been blowing a gasket. You sound cool and collected. Having a lemsip and a little cry was a great idea - I would have been in there shouting

Hope you feel better soon!

franklymydear · 29/07/2009 11:45

does it? must be where I'm going wrong then

thehairybabysmum · 29/07/2009 12:33

Bec i love the way you had all under total control later!!

I hate the over emoting thing too it just sounds so bloody sappy!

Honestly have a look at the counting thing, it works with no tantrums.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

becstarlitsea · 29/07/2009 17:01

Oh you're all so kind! I actually thought that having a lemsip and a little cry was a mark of my failure, so I feel more cheerful about that now

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page