Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Is a diagnosis really that important???

30 replies

TruckTheBend · 12/04/2009 17:55

(Namechanged for various reasons)
Have DD (7) and DS (3).
DS has never had any developemental delays, in fact seems rather bright and reached all milestones pretty much in the middle of "normal" range. But he has funny little ways which have really always been there with him but we are now at a stage where other people are picking up on them and passing comment/offering advice/ querying the cause etc.
He gets on fine with other children but has some boundary issues and doesn't always read signals from them to back off.
He tends to repeat back pretty much everything - word for word- that is said to him, although he still carries a normal (norm for a 3yo anyway) conversation.
He has a variety of obsessions which at times bring him coimfort and at other times seem to cause him anxiety.
He has some, but not many, rituals and becomes upset if these are deviated from.
He seems to be over-sensiive to noise and when upset can tolerate almost no noise at all. His eating is extremely restricted in terms of variety and texture though luckily what he does eat is prety nutritious.
There are lots of other little things he does that do mark him out as different and certainly i never experienced these things with DD, but on the whole he is a very happy, confident bright boy. He is loving and tactile, humorous and is very empathetic to emotions etc.
Some family members have commented, but its just from DH's side and tbh they are all a bit obsessed with labels!
I have a friend who works with SN children and although she s being extremely tactful I know she feels we should begin the process of having him tested (seems the wrong word? mind gone blank im afraid)for ASD.
Now I have been approached by mgr at DS's nursery about his "quirks", she did this in a gentle way, it didn t feel as though she was pushing me to any conclusions i rather got the feeling she wanted to see where my thoughts were on it all but i now fully expect a more official discussion where their worries are raised.
The problem I have is that i dont thin i want to go down the route of medicalising him. He is happy and healthy and as a family we will continue to ensure that that is the case.
I ahve to admit that i have looked into ASD and see definite striking similarities but then i als dont see alot of the markers either.
I fully understand that DS would at least be a candidate for testing (again with the testing?! screening maybe??) but i just dont want it, i dont think a diagnosos is necessary and its not like i could go through the process and accept the result if it says he is not on the spectrum but refuse it if he is, is it? If I start this and he gets the diagnosis then theres no turning back, he will be labelled forever.
I tend to think that even if he is asd then he is certainly at the very mild end and can foresee no problems with him in general life.
I also kind of think lots of adults are making their way through the world just fine who could very probably be considered asd. Maybe we are all on there to one extent or another?!
Am I underestimating the situation?
Are others maybe overstating it?
Any experience/ advice/ ideas greatly appreciated.

OP posts:
OonaghBhuna · 13/04/2009 20:27

I think getting a diagnosis can be a positive thing rather than just a label. My nephew was diagnosed with mild asd last year. Although it was an extremely emotional and difficult time for my sister it has actually meant that my nephew gets the appropriate support that he needs.We also have a better understanding of his behaviour which can be quite challenging at times.

Early intervention is the key for any child with any difficulty whether its mild moderate or severe.

tclanger · 13/04/2009 20:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

IheartEASTEREGGS · 13/04/2009 20:48

I'm pretty much in the same situation as you OP.
My DS is 3.5 and displaying a lot of the same signs. My HV has spotted it and I have agreed to be referred to a paed after a lot of thought on the matter.
The reasons I have gone for the referal are:
I would rather he is labelled with 'ASD' than 'Naughty' at school
He already needs speech therapy and I want to make sure he has access to any other help he may need at school
I have a 14 year old brother with Aspergers and I know from experience that the mild eccentricities DS is displaying now will become more pronounced as he gets older and make things harder for him without the dx and extra help
I want to feel that I have done everything I can for him to ensure a happy and smooth life ahead for him. I cant bear to think that his food fussiness/issues could turn into an eating disorder for example and am going to make sure I get all the advice/tips I can from professionals to make sure that doesnt happen..

Those are obviously just my personal reasons and there are still drawbacks too.
I think you've got to go with what feels right for you and your DS right now and keep re-assessing as time goes on.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

lingle · 13/04/2009 20:54

Seems like it all depends whether the diagnosis is a condition of getting the help. That is crucial.

StarlightMcEggzie · 13/04/2009 20:58

I was told better a lable of ASD than a lable of 'naughty', 'uncooperative' or 'difficult'.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page