Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

How to handle aggressive outbursts in a 5yo boy

30 replies

Harrjenk · 26/03/2026 19:50

Hi, I would really appreciate some kind advice please. My 5 year old son is generally a complete joy- enthusiastic, fun, doing brilliantly at school, swimming etc, He is loving and tactile and has been a brilliant and caring older brother to his 6 month old sister. But he has always been incredibly defiant, and recently he’s been starting to have these angry outbursts where he turns really violent. He’s strong and he can really hurt me now. I’m talking kicking, punching, grabbing my hair, throwing things at me (shoes, remote control), stabbing at me with a fork or pen. I try desperately to stay calm during these situations but I’m so triggered by being hurt and I’m also always trying to keep his baby sister away from this so she doesn’t become collateral damage (it’s never aimed at her but she is usually on me). It’s very quick to happen. Today I ended up shouting at him when he wouldn’t stop running at me with a cutlery knife. For context, they had the most insane amount of cake and Easter eggs at school today and I’m sure that didn’t help.
The meltdown today started because I said No to having more Easter eggs and he grabbed the bag and started gobbling them and I took them off him. I recognize he was tired and overstimulated.

im just not sure the best way to handle it. I want to be kind and understanding and have him feel he can come to me when he‘s angry. If I try I to talk about it after he just shuts down and changes the subject. I’ve read There’s Still No Such Thing As Naughty but nothing I try from there seems to work. And the Crisis Management part doesn’t work at all in the moment. I’m feeling so tired and beleaguered by it all. I solo parent 90% of the time. For context there is no violence in our home, so it’s not a learned behavior from us.

Do I just wait this phase out? Do I seek help? What does he need from me to support him through this? How do I stay calm in the moment (please don’t say deep breaths and count to ten!). Thanks

OP posts:
Harrjenk · 29/03/2026 07:53

Thanks everyone. Haven’t got time to reply individually but have had a read through. In response to some questions, the “punch the pillow” idea came from the No Such Thing As Naughty Book.

and Yes he’s amazing at School, really well behaved, sociable and achieving in loads of areas. This behaviour is solely an afterschool thing so there must be some relation there. His Dad is away a lot with no notice so it’s hard for us all to get to grips with. We are also all moving away this summer and then of course there is having his baby sister so lots of change for him to navigate,

I don’t believe shouting back at home helps- as some have said it escalates the situation and I feel out of control myself. And I can’t put him in his own room or remove him as of course he won’t stay there as he’s out of control himself. There’s no where I can lock him in! Removing myself means he’s not getting attention in those moments until he calms down which seems to be working. And I’ve also enacted some pretty big consequences to try and break the habit like “if you hit me between now and tomorrow we won’t go to X’s birthday party tomorrow” etc .

my upbringing was cold and we weren’t allowed to feel anything really, we were
told to deal with any negative emotions by ourselves in our rooms. I’ve struggled with this a lot of my adult life in many ways so I’m trying to not repeat that. I’d lke my son to be able to feel the anger but learn to deal with it better- something I never was taught to do.

OP posts:
Harrjenk · 29/03/2026 08:27

Also definitely agree with someone’s comment about it being a power struggle- since starting school there’s been a lot of “boys are stronger, boys play football, boys don’t feel sad etc”. Definitely doesn’t come from us!! There’s only two girls in his whole class. So I think he’s trying to figure this out in the context of our house, who’s in charge etc

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 29/03/2026 18:09

I can’t put him in his own room or remove him as of course he won’t stay there as he’s out of control himself. There’s no where I can lock him in! Removing myself means he’s not getting attention in those moments until he calms down which seems to be working.

If you have found a way to do this which is working then that is good. Sometimes if I really can't get space because one of my DC is following me, I have locked myself in the bathroom, or sat on the other side of a door so that it can't be opened.

I’d lke my son to be able to feel the anger but learn to deal with it better- something I never was taught to do.

In general, the best way to do this is outside of the moment. You can't do any kind of teaching of anger management when they're already angry. However you can do a lot of talking about emotions, thinking about strategies to use, practising strategies etc at calmer moments and then the more familiar he is with them, the more likely he is to be able to use them when he is feeling angry.

I’ve also enacted some pretty big consequences to try and break the habit like “if you hit me between now and tomorrow we won’t go to X’s birthday party tomorrow” etc .

Again if this is working, then I do not mean to stop, because I am a full believer in different things work for different families.

However, IME sometimes the problem with big consequences is that you can end up threatening something you really don't want to have to follow through and that can be hard to manage as you find yourself looking for loopholes, which undermines the authority you're trying to create with the threat. Or another possibility is that you threaten something in relation to a condition which is actually really hard for the child to meet. I mean, hopefully "no hitting me for 1 day" isn't too hard to meet, and indeed, sometimes you can find out from something like this that what you assumed was too hard for them is actually something they can control, if you actually respond to it consistently enough. But depending on the child's other skills (e.g. communication) they are able to access while frustrated, their impulse control, and their ability to retain non-immediate consequences in mind in order to alter their behaviour in the present, sometimes it's legitimately too big of an expectation and they will not be able to manage. When this is the case, the big consequences quickly become counterproductive as they are not working anyway, the child feels it is unfair/impossible and you end up punishing them all the time or even running out of things to take away, or removing things for so long that the child doesn't even register it as a punishment any more.

If you're getting stuck in that cycle, there are two things you can do to alleviate it.

One is to break the behaviour expectation down into smaller parts, which might mean a smaller time period (like schools often use behaviour charts which track behaviour per lesson rather than having the expectation that the child behave perfectly all day before they receive a reward for this effort) or might mean steps between the current behaviour and the expected behaviour. And if it's still not helping, then break it down further.

The other thing is to have a consequence which is really small and generic and temporary, so that it feels less like a weapon and more like a penalty, and so that it has an effect whether you have to use it 1x or several and it doesn't ever run out. Or you can flip with a tiny incremental reward which is either gained when they do the thing over a short period of time or assumed to be given each day but can be lost for any incidence of a behaviour.

And what is important with both of these things IME is to keep the behaviour expectation/consequence structure clear and consistent, so it doesn't feel like he's fighting against you but he's working within a clear system, and then you can be on his side. Like you don't want him to lose his 1p or his screen time any more than he wants to lose it, so you can work with him to remind him of his methods to manage anger for example.

One of the benefits of the consequence being temporary and/or the period of time being short is that it means they always have a chance to try again, which is important otherwise they get discouraged from trying to change their behaviour.

Harrjenk · 29/03/2026 20:28

@BertieBotts thanks for the thoughtful answer!

OP posts:
canuckup · 30/03/2026 01:35

What kxn said

All this pussy footing around explaining feelings to a five year old lad doesn't work. He needs telling and showing where the line is.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page