They are 10 & 14 now, but we have been strict since they first started using video games. We had a vintage console, which they played with DH when they were quite little (5ish). We chose a Nintendo switch because of the parental settings - access can be password controlled, when the time runs out they get a 5 minute warning and then it just stops. In the beginning we were heavy on discouraging the tantrums, and they learned that huge outbursts would reduce game time, not be rewarded with more.
We stick to (mostly) a strict Friday-Sunday game days with short game durations. They don’t play online. (Though DS1 does now play occasionally midweek, as long as homework is done and he’s cleared up after himself and it’s still early enough to have screen free time before a sensible bed time. He’s also allowed to play online, occasionally, with one or two friends/his cousin. But this is all heavily restricted).
DH bought it for himself, it doesn’t belong to the children. Same with DS1’s phone - it’s not his phone, it’s my old one, on my contract, charged with our electricity, running on our WiFi. So our rules.
Before DS1 had a smart phone we discussed how damaging social media & unregulated screen use is. We were clear from the outset that we would be heavily restricting what he would be allowed to use. He could be cross with us, he could blame us, but while he was young it was our job to ensure he had a full range of experiences in real life.
We do get the occasional grumps, but find that if expectations are managed and boundaries are clear, negotiation in advance is reasonable, then they understand and we get minimal pushback.
We also find that they have learned to be creative, to deal with boredom, to lean into a more 90s childhood than some of their peers and will go out to play etc.
They haven’t yet worked out the passwords (I think). We do often discuss why we’re doing this, how we’ve seen more permissive situations ultimately harm children. How going outside is scary for parents but is much safer than being online. About how for many of these apps, their attention is the product being sold, and this makes those rich men richer.
We will probably have more pushback in the future, but we thought it probably best to start strict and gradually allow more, rather than pulling it back when they were older. Same for homework & routines.
I recommend reading Jonathan Haidt’s The Anxious Generation.
(And yes, I do use the screen time settings and Screen Zen to help manage my own phone use, I’ve had to use 2 of my 6 uses just writing this reply this evening! We are all subject to this kind of digital crack).