Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Extending The Family Woe with Husband

8 replies

MummyxK · 21/08/2023 07:04

Hello all,
I joined this community for your advice if possible please. I’m in turmoil about what to do and what’s best for the family and mainly our daughter.

I was counting down to May this year, as my husband mentioned that would be the time to extend the family. Something I’ve always wanted. We currently have a 3 year old and she is so kind and caring; she’d just love a sibling to play with and care for.
May came and I brought up the topic but my husband said he wasn’t sure how to tell me he doesn’t want another child. He’s been feeling that way for over a year or so and didn’t know how to tell me. Even though, in the months before May, he was with me at the pharmacy getting the pre-pregnancy supplements.

Some context: When I gave birth to our daughter in Covid, I was on my own for several days after the birth in the hospital with no visitors allowed. I hadn’t slept a wink and discharged myself for wanting to be at home for rest and to be with my husband.
The first night at home, I got some sleep but the following morning, my husband was in tears that he needed his Mum… Some sort of depression hit when I got home and he’s sought help over the years with it. He’s partially worried his depression will come back at the birth of our next child and doesn’t want to go through it again, which is understandable but I’ve tried to be supportive and say he could get help again if he starts to feel unwell. I’d be there again and he wouldn’t be alone. I wouldn’t want him to be unwell so he could speak to someone professionally again before the birth perhaps and thereafter? Also, what are the chances it’ll return? We’ve done all this before with our first child but I know the mind works differently.

He’s also got this attachment to his Mum, and his Mum with him, which doesn’t help him. He longs to be with his family (we’re a 2.5 hr drive away) and he wants us to move to the same town as them. That would be his wish if he could have it. But I have my elderly mother a few towns away from us and I can’t leave her, and she wouldn’t move with us. The families aren’t close and have hardly met. She doesn’t have any family herself and neighbours as her friends. I couldn’t take her away from the house I grew up in, and she’s spent so much love recently in trying to update it.

My husband has given me an ultimatum with the second baby. I could possibly have one if I move to his parent’s town (because he wants the support of his Mum), or be happy with the way things are as a family of 3 now.

I understand he doesn’t want to become ill again. I wouldn’t want him to go through that again but I feel he’s being unreasonable and unfair. There’s no compromise for me unless I move away from my own Mum who has helped raise our daughter - she visits four days a week and has done for 3 years.

His other reasonings are giving up his games room for the baby, not being able to afford nice holidays, the fear we’ll argue even more, having no help around us, won’t afford nice things.

It’s just all him and there’s no understanding for what I want. I’ve come from a divorced family, I lost my twin brother many years ago and I don’t want our daughter growing up on her own and having no sibling in the future like me. It’s been a painful few months and I’m just not close with my husband any more. I don’t want to break the family up but I don’t know what to do about all this.
He’s not budging and I’m in such a state some days knowing I’m not going to be pregnant again and not going to have that second child. It’s hard seeing families around with siblings playing, and I must have not supported him well enough for him to feel he could manage another child. I don’t know if I can forget all this.

I’ve kept everything from my first pregnancy too. Cots, clothes, bouncers, you name it as I thought this is what we wanted. But I’m in the midst of clearing out clothes and trying to sell them which is painful.

I’d just love to hear opinions if possible. I’m just frazzled by it all and what to do for the best.

Thank you if you’ve managed to read my essay to the end! x

OP posts:
DustyLee123 · 21/08/2023 07:08

Your child does not ‘need’ a sibling. The fact is that you can’t both win. You either stay with him, keep the family together and simmer with resentment until you hit menopause, or you leave and have a baby with someone else. Only you can decide which it will be.

Azaeleasinbloom · 21/08/2023 07:39

Losing a twin, or indeed any sibling, must be very hard, so I can see where you are coming from there. But being an ‘only’ but much loved child is not the same at all.

You are blaming yourself - ‘I must not have supported him well enough’ - OP, he is supposed to be your partner, and as a parent already he needs to take responsibility for himself.

I would be concerned that moving close to his mum would result in him abdicating all adult responsibilities , and then you are contending with possibly 2 young children, a man-child, and a MIL interfering in your life.

Please think on whether a second child, with this man, is in anyone’s interests.

HerMammy · 21/08/2023 08:11

Crying for his mum when you've just given birth?
He sounds like a selfish child with no thoughts to your feelings.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

YetAnotherSpartacus · 21/08/2023 08:22

Why are you with this inadequate, selfish man-child who cries for his mummy?

You know that if you move closer (leaving your own mother in the lurch) he and mummy will team up against you.

What support does he actually provide for you? Or is it all about him?

Peachespeachesohpeaches · 21/08/2023 08:32

You both sound enmeshed with your mum's. He wants to closer to his so much so he's issuing ultimatums and you see yours 4 times and a week and she's helping raise your DD. If he's close to his mum and wants to be closer, I can see how your mum being so heavily involved might upset him. Equally you don't want to leave yours or ask her to uproot her life to facilitate his move which is understandable. It's all a bit of a mess. Perhaps some relationship counselling might help?

Re the depression, yes he could get help before and after - it might not be the same feeling again and he needs to seek appropriate support.

Acheyknees · 21/08/2023 08:37

What's he like as a father? I'd find the crying for his Mum particularly unattractive and worrying.
Is he someone you can rely on? Having 2 children can be full on, he needs to be totally on board with having 2 but it sounds like he'd run back to his Mum when things get hard.

plumtreebroke · 21/08/2023 08:52

I can see how he got depressed, you in hospital with a new born and he can't visit you. Him at home worried and alone, I can understand he might 'want' his mum to help him with it. I don't think it would be the same again, he would be with you a lot of the time and he wouldn't have to be worried alone at home.

Maybe a counsellor of some sort could talk him through how different it would be next time. Could his mum come to stay sometimes, so he feels she is part of the family as well, not just your mum? You could promise she could come and stay for the birth (not sure you would like that but...) so he would have her with him to help him cope if it does start to go downhill.

MummyxK · 21/08/2023 16:34

Thank you all for your comments and advice. It’s nice to get an outsiders perspective on the situation. I appreciate it a lot.

Yes, it was a bit worrying when he got upset after I returned home from hospital. He sought help then and has done since. He seems in a good place now, which I thought was why we were waiting to try again to get pregnant this year.

He is helpful and is a good playful Daddy to our daughter.

I’ve suggested couples counselling before but he’s never been too keen.

I kind of know I have to suck it up and just deal with him not wanting another child but it’s hard to accept with the reasonings he’s given me. There’s resentment there but I guess it’s just moving on with it now.
We have a home with enough space and we aren’t struggling too much with money and time, so I feel we are capable of doing it but he just simply is done and is giving me a lot of ‘practical’ excuses why he doesn’t / can’t have one - including, he enjoys his free time again with seeing friends, gaming and sleeping through the night. Can’t really compete with that. I just feel my needs don’t matter.

Thank you all again!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page