Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Car seat

6 replies

Mrs22 · 11/11/2022 16:46

Hey all I need a new car seat for ds 6 months. Just put him in the 0+ car seat that came with my travel system and he's starting to outgrow it. He is a big baby he's in 9-12 clothes allready. While looking for car seats I read if they have the white buckle adjuster that they are dangerous as they fail if crash is stronger than 40mph. Is this right? When I'm searching car seats they all have the white buckle on them. Can anyone recommend a car seat under 80 quid that they think is good? I don't put him in car to much maybe once a month so it's not gonna get massive use out of it. Thanks x

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Lockdownmummy · 11/11/2022 17:30

First of all I'd check that he is definitely growing out of his infant seat. What's is the weight limit? Have you taken out all the inserts? My small 14 month old is still
In her infant seat.

I get that you don't want to spend too much as it's for occasional use but if you could stretch to £100-£120 a Joie Stages might work. I also understand that Graco seats are the same as Joie so maybe take a look at those.

Mrs22 · 13/11/2022 06:31

Thanks for your reply. It's ickle bubba astral car seat. I feel really stupid now didn't realise the insert comes out its my 1st baby so I had no clue 🤣 he fits in it now. Am now looking for a car seat for when he gets to a year old least I can now do allot of research. Still getting conflicting info online regarding the white harness clips. X

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 13/11/2022 06:51

The white harness clips mean that the seat is probably made by a company called team Tex who make generic seats for different companies that all put their own covers on the seats and sell them under different names. That's why people warn about this harness style because it's an easy way to recognise that the seat is generic.

Generic seats tend to be built for cost rather than safety. You want to look at brands which build their own seats as they have more of a focus on safety. Joie as mentioned previously and Graco are good budget options. I've also found some of the cosy n safe and babyauto seats to be good budget options.

However it's a bit out of date because there are other generic brands that are not using that harness style now.

The story behind the 40mph claim is a bit less black and white - the crash test to legally sell a car seat is done at 30mph and in 2012 there was one team Tex seat with that harness style which was crash tested by the company that supplies Which? with their crash test results, this crash test is done to the NCAP conditions and is at 40mph. Generic seats, of which many have been team Tex, because they were the leading provider of generic seats in Europe for a long time, have been known to get worse scores in this test. The seat that was tested in 2012 broke and the harness detached from the seat. That model was recalled, although they do still sell a very similar looking one. I don't know if they changed the design. You'd hope so, but it's not unknown for a company not to do that. Technically it's perfectly legal because it does not fail in the test for the legal approval.

But that doesn't mean that all team Tex seats will necessarily fail at higher speeds, that's not really how it works.

If you're on a tight budget the best thing you can do is keep your baby rear facing for as long as possible. Joie and Graco have some good seats that will let you rear face to 18kg. The reason for this is that it doesn't matter how basic the seat is, rear facing is very protective and you can get good protection without spending a lot. However these seats tend not to do as well when used forward facing.

I would probably recommend the Joie steadi, or if you can keep using your seat as long as possible (at least 15 months) and you're definitely sure you don't want to rear face, maxi Cosi Tobi is the best performing belt fitted one.

You may also want to look into impact shield type seats. I found those useful when I didn't have my own car because they are easier to fit quickly. However please be aware despite better safety scores in tests, they don't actually offer any better safety than a standard forward facing seat, because they have higher incidence of other kinds of injury that aren't tested for in those tests.

Rear facing for as long as possible is the safest option without spending much money. But I agree that a £100 budget would be better if you can stretch to it at all. Some of the very cheap seats really are very flimsy. Another option is to ask around friends and family if they have a stage 2 seat they have finished using, although bear the same advice in mind about brands and rear facing. It's not advised to buy car seats second hand as you don't know the history of it.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

TheRookie · 13/11/2022 07:10

I've never seen a white buckle on a car seat before? Look at Joie or maxi cosi, reputable companies who make loads of car seats. I like the Joie spin.

tirednewmumm · 13/11/2022 07:29

Joie is good we have the joie stages, yes I would also avoid the white buckle team tex seats I've seen some horrid safety data for them. We got ours on klarna because we weren't willing to compromise on safety, that might be an option if you've now got a bit longer to sort it

Lavender2021 · 13/11/2022 07:50

Don't buy a seat with the white clips. They have been known to fall apart in crashes. Unfortunately many companies use them, even John Lewis!
Joie do a range of car seat's that you can rear face in until 18kg or outgrown height wise.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread